臺灣慰安婦劇場:論同黨劇團《燃燒的蝴蝶》之內褶交織與戲史轉譯
Comfort Women Theatre in Taiwan: On Drama-History Translation and Folded Intersectionality of The Party Theatre Group’s Burning Butterfly
國立臺灣大學臺灣文學研究所(Graduate Institute of Taiwan Literature, National Taiwan University)
摘要
從九○年代開始的臺灣慰安婦對日求償運動,始終未能獲得日本政府正式承
認或完整賠償。冷戰遺緒與當前熱戰之中,隨著所知最後一位前臺籍慰安婦受難
者於2023年過世,有關議題越陷艱難,更體現歷史創傷、戰爭論述、性別與暴力
系統緊密共構的迫切人權命題。近三十年來,婦女救援基金會等組織為受難者動
員求償運動,更為之提供照護及情感輔導支援,也激發以慰安婦為主題的文化與
藝術創作多元發展。其中,有關慰安婦議題的臺灣劇場日漸成蹊,然而,慰安婦
作為戰爭之性暴力受難者,往往處於一種難以觸碰或討論的「內褶交織」狀態,
目前有關慰安婦劇場的研究評論卻往往聚焦於歷史考證足夠與否,以及史料轉譯
適當與否的辯論框架中,忽略慰安婦劇場的雙層悖論本質,亦即歷史的不可絕對
再現性,以及舞臺再現企圖與受難者不願再現之間的矛盾性。鑑此,本文爬梳近
年以慰安婦為主題之臺灣劇場與表演藝術,分析美學策略與社會運動之間的互動
模式與後續效果,並聚焦同黨劇團於2022年推出之《燃燒的蝴蝶》。此劇呈現臺
籍慰安婦受難故事,一方面藉由抽象偶戲展演歷史悲劇,寓言慰安婦受難經驗之
凹陷塌藏;另一方面則透過寫實表演陳述現今創痛,透過敘事版本的塌陷,反向
揭露被暴力同質化的從屬與裸命,由此指向戲史轉譯所締造的「共享的無法共享
性」。
Abstract
The movement for Taiwan’s comfort women to seek redress from Japan,
which began in the 1990s, has persistently failed to secure formal acknowledgment
or comprehensive compensation from the Japanese government. In the context of
Cold War legacies and current geopolitical tensions, the passing of the last known
surviving Taiwanese comfort woman in 2023 highlights the increasing difficulty
of addressing the issue. This event underscores the urgent human rights concerns
intricately linked with historical traumas, war narratives, and systems of gendered
violence. Over the past three decades, organizations such as Taipei Women’s Rescue
Foundation have mobilized campaigns for survivors, providing them with care and
emotional counseling. These efforts have also stimulated the diverse development
of cultural and artistic creations centered on the theme of comfort women. In this
context, Taiwanese theater addressing the issue of comfort women has gradually gained
attention. However, as victims of sexual violence during wartime, comfort women
often occupy a state of what this essay calls as “folded intersectionality,” rendering
their experiences difficult to approach or discuss. Current research and critiques
of comfort women theater remain confined within debates over the sufficiency of
historical documentation and the appropriateness of historical translation. This narrow
focus neglects the inherent double paradox of comfort women theatre—namely, the
impossibility of absolute historical representation and the contradiction between the
desire to stage representation and the survivors’ reluctance to be represented. In light of
this, this essay examines theater and performing arts centered on the theme of comfort
women in Taiwan, analyzing the interaction between aesthetic strategies and social
movements and their subsequent impacts, with a special focus on The Party Theatre’s
Burning Butterfly (2022). This production portrays the tragic stories of Taiwanese
comfort women, employing two distinct yet interconnected approaches. On one hand,
it utilizes abstract puppet theater to represent the historical tragedy, allegorizing the
unrepresentability of the comfort women’s traumatic experiences. On the other hand, it
incorporates realistic performances to articulate present trauma, exposing through the
collapse of narrative frameworks the violent homogenization of the subaltern and bare
life. In doing so, the play gestures toward the “shared unshareability” forged through
the theatrical translation of history.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 戲劇研究
- ISSN
- 2070-2663
- 卷期
- 35期
- 出版
- 2025年01月
- 頁碼
- 031–060
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005643
同期目錄
- 1910-1940 年代「戲迷傳」的跨文類傳播現象與迷文化葉霑(Jan YEH)・頁 001–030
- 臺灣慰安婦劇場:論同黨劇團《燃燒的蝴蝶》之內褶交織與戲史轉譯鄭芳婷(Fan-ting CHENG)・頁 031–060
- 劇烈加速度下的遠程藝術:以國家兩廳院 5G 計畫製作之《神不在的小鎮》、《向左走向右走─心電感應版》與《Operation 1’71701’/彌─見證日:終末之戰》為例邱誌勇(Chih-yung CHIU)・頁 061–090
- 現代性諧擬:袁牧之電影中的上海都會生活再現許仁豪(Jen-hao Walter HSU)・頁 091–120