場面調度.表演事件─歐陸劇場表演分析的兩大取向及其侷限
Mise en scène.Performance Event─Approaches to Performance Analysis and their Limitations
國立臺南大學戲劇創作與應用學系(Department of Drama Creation and Application, National University of Tainan)
摘要
當代劇場演出現象不僅傳統與現代樣態並立,混合跨界型態也日益增多,
除了導致藝術邊界的模糊,亦生發愈來愈多踐行(performativity)性質的劇場表
演。這些性質殊異但卻又有交集重疊的演出,我們該如何去欣賞、分析與辨識其
屬性?基於此,了解歐陸劇場研究中的表演分析(performance analysis)領域及
其論辯,應有助於我們辨識當今多元紛雜的演出現象。一九六零年代歐陸劇場研
究發展以劇場符號學為主的表演分析理論與方法,經過半世紀,表演分析理論與
方法隨表演現象不斷更新和多元化,經歷種種論辯,已成為歐陸劇場學術界重要
研究區塊,並被視為是二十世紀以來劇場作為一獨立學科的成果之一,同時也是
繼傳統戲劇文本分析之後,對劇場本體提出的理論與分析方法。雖然表演分析的
眾多取徑吸收了來自不同領域的理論(如符號學、現象學、詮釋學、觀眾接受與
傳播理論),但皆經過劇場表演分析理論家提煉、釐清、重新系統化、再理論
化、並賦予特定的劇場術語,使這些理論與劇場是可以直接對接。
本文論旨除探討表演分析發展和理論脈絡,主要關切點將著力於表演分析
領域理論中的兩大重要分析取向:場面調度(mise en scène)與表演/劇場事件
(performance/theatrical event),前者關注對製作面/作品端的分析,後者傾向
探討演出當下的表演者與觀眾之間的關係。在不同取向下,諸理論家對表演的類
型學(typology)也有不同思考與界定,此有助於我們對於劇場表演本體結構文
本的辨識,並在當代劇場表演類型的交疊、跨域、質變的複雜演出現象中,藉由
對表演分析理論的探詢和釐清,提供分析者不同思路和取向,以作為分析表演的參考。此外,本文亦將析論表演分析的某些侷限,特別是對此一頗為歐洲中心之
劇場理論資源,對亞洲劇場的適用性和缺陷提出思考。
Abstract
Apart from the increasing phenomena of hybrid and cross-border arts
collaboration, and the blurring of artistic genre boundaries in contemporary theatre
performance, performativity-oriented performances have grown substantially in theater
performances. Theatre performances no longer stay within the scope of drama and
theatre. Here comes a difficulty: how do we attribute clear properties to theatrical/nontheatrical
performances which are different and yet somehow overlapped? Theories
and different perspectives of performance analysis might give clues. Around the
1960s, theatre studies in Europe developed theories and methods of performance
analysis based on theater semiotics. With the emerging performance phenomena and
influential American performance studies, its theories and methods have been updated
and diversified, and formed one of the foundations of theater academia. Even though
drawing on theories from outside the theatre world (such as semiotics, phenomenology,
hermeneutics, audience reception and communication), they are resystematized,
retheorized, and assigned specific theater terms by theatre theorists so that they can be
connected with the field of theater and properly applied to performance.
In addition to discussing the development and theoretical context of
performance analysis, this paper aims at two analytical approaches in performance
analysis: mise en scène and performance/theatrical event. The former focuses on the
production side, while the latter tends to explore the relationship between the performer
and the audience at the moment of the performance. It is worth noting that, under
different perspectives, the theorists proposed typologies of performance which help to
identify textual structures in both theatrical and non-theatrical performances, and are
essential for analyzing performance.
One needs to be aware, however, that performance analysis is a Westerncentric
theoretical resource developed for/from Western theatre tradition. Although
Asian modern and contemporary theatres have been greatly influenced by Western
theatre, Asian theatre traditions and aesthetics, fundamentally differed from the West.
Performance analysis developed by the West thus is surely not sufficient for those influenced by or rooted in Asian traditional theatre concepts. Analytical strategies that
integrate Western analytical theories and different, specific Asian aesthetics thus should
be considered and further developed.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 戲劇研究
- ISSN
- 2070-2663
- 卷期
- 30期
- 出版
- 2022年07月
- 頁碼
- 139–188
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005663
同期目錄
- 詩筆與史筆:論蔣士銓《一片石》雜劇的詩體淵源及其歷史反思邱嘉耀(Ka-yiu YAU)・頁 001–036
- 論田漢的南國小劇場運動與築地小劇場的淵源盧敏芝(Man-chi LO)・頁 037–072
- 一九三○年代上海改良文明戲的實踐及其批判徐亞湘(Ya-hsiang HSU)・頁 073–102
- 在藝術與愛情之間:論袁牧之早期戲劇實踐的主體辯證法許仁豪(Jen-hao HSU)・頁 103–138
- 場面調度.表演事件─歐陸劇場表演分析的兩大取向及其侷限林偉瑜(Wei-yu LIN)・頁 139–188