從《李爾王》到豫莎劇《天問》:中國化語境下的教化衝動與改編議題
From King Lear to Questioning Heaven: The Urge to Edify in Chinese Cultural and Linguistic Contexts and Its Issues of Adaptation
國立臺南大學戲劇創作與應用學系(Department of Drama Creation and Application, National University of Tainan)
摘要
臺灣從一九八O年代開始出現以戲曲改編、搬演西方經典,三十多年來已形
成一股蓬勃的風潮。其中,可能唯有臺灣豫劇團與莎士比亞著名學者彭鏡禧和戲
曲學者陳芳合作的豫莎劇三部曲有發展出一套固定的改編原則。包括二OO九
年改編自《威尼斯商人》的《約/束》、二O一二年改編自《一報還一報》的
《量.度》與二O一五年改編自《李爾王》的《天問》,都是遵循同一套改編原
則:時空移植為中國古代,企圖貼近原著精義,並高度強調語言的文學性。改編
者陳芳也從此改編策略衍生,發展跨文化改編的實務運作方法,並以此評論其他
莎戲曲,形成改編美學與建構評論理論,值得受到審視。
本篇論文第一部分先梳理豫莎劇改編者的意識形態、理論形成與改編策略,
審視其改編原則,揭露可能隱藏的假定,並提供不同的思考點,尤其是何謂劇場
的語言文學性。第二部分分析《天問》的文本展現與可能的問題,以闡述此改編
策略形成不可抑制的「教化衝動」,導致主要人物只能扮演倫常次序上最重要的
角色:明君與忠臣;忠臣的刻劃單一,王后的情感強度,與劇本傳達的思想性均
因此被削弱。本文第三部分進一步將戲曲的跨文化改編置於臺灣戲曲改革的大脈
絡下,來思考改編者「戲曲主體性」的論述與當代觀眾可能的接收回應,再度
提出「時代感知」(sensibility)的改編觀點;同時,強調在現代臺灣「此時此
地」的時空下,重新思考戲曲主體性的可能內涵。
Abstract
In the past three decades, Taiwan has witnessed a popular practice of adapting
western canonical works into various types of xiqu (traditional opera) performances.
Among these numerous adaptations, probably only the three plays of Taiwan Bangzi
Opera Company’s Shakespeare’s Trilogy have followed a consistent set of principles
of adaptation, developed by their adaptors Perng Ching-Hsi and Chen Fang. These
three works, Bond (2009) adapted from The Merchant of Venice, Measure, Measure!
(2012) from Measure for Measure, and Questioning Heaven (2015) from King Lear,
with the setting transferred to ancient feudal China, strive to be as close to the essence
of the original as possible, and aim to achieve a high literary quality due to their great
emphasis on the beauty of language in Shakespeare’s works. From these principles,
Chen Fang has further developed a system of adapting Shakespeare into xiqu and
has applied this system in her critique of other intercultural xiqu performances. Such
discourses need to be examined because they are not just adaptation strategies, but have
formed a kind of theoretical criticism.
In the first part of this article, I examine these principles of adaptation to
uncover their hidden assumptions, explore the problems such strategies may cause, and
provide different perspectives in terms of what counts as “literary quality” in theatre.
In part two, I focus on one specific problem in Questioning Heaven--its urge to edify
(or, exhibiting strong didactic intent) in the Chinese linguistic and cultural context.
This urge limits the characterization of three main characters, who can play nothing
else but loyal court officials and king, the most important in traditional Chinese human
relations as taught by Confucius. Thus, the two loyal officials become stereotypes,
the emotional intensity of King Lear is reduced, and the thought explored in the
play is narrowed. In addition, the urge to edify arises not just from the strategies of
using Chinese idioms, but also from what adaptor Chen Fang calls “the subjectivity
of xiqu”—in content, following Confucian culture as always expressed in xiqu ; and
in performing, renovating the stage conventions within its recognizable frame. In
the third and final part of this article, situating Questioning Heaven in the theatrical contexts of Taiwan—that is, the reform of xiqu and its fashionable trend of intercultural
adaptation—I propose revisiting modern sensibility as a principle of adaptation, and
more importantly, what the content of xiqu subjectivity could be in Taiwan here and
now.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 戲劇研究
- ISSN
- 2070-2663
- 卷期
- 20期
- 出版
- 2017年07月
- 頁碼
- 065–102
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005707
同期目錄
- 摩登與激進的變奏:談張獻早期戲劇與上海現代性的關聯許仁豪(Jen-hao HSU)・頁 001–038
- 從星光到鐘聲:張維賢的新劇生涯及其困境邱坤良(Kun-liang CHIU)・頁 039–064
- 從《李爾王》到豫莎劇《天問》:中國化語境下的教化衝動與改編議題林雯玲(Wen-ling LIN)・頁 065–102
- 二十一世紀在韓國舞臺上的《趙氏孤兒》──中國古典戲劇的當代化與在地化吳秀卿(Sookyung OH)・頁 103–134