吳蘭徵之《絳蘅秋》
Wu Lanzheng's Jiang Heng Qiu
加州大學柏克萊分校東亞語言文化學系暨比較文學系(Departments of East Asian Languages and Cultures and Comparative Literature,
University of California at Berkeley)
摘要
吳蘭徵的《絳蘅秋》是唯一一部由女性作家書寫的《紅樓夢》續集。在吳蘭
徵三十歲逝世時,該劇並沒有完成。她的丈夫俞用濟(字遙帆)將該劇編入《零
香集》,該集包含有吳蘭徵的悼念詩、祭文、俞用濟和朋友書寫的吳的傳記,並
且將其出版。吳蘭徵的筆名明確地證實了她將自己視為後來的林黛玉。在這篇文
章中,我將探討《紅樓夢》以何種方式參與進後來林黛玉形象的化身過程。我將
提出吳蘭徵在《絳蘅秋》中對林黛玉的描述如何以作者自比黛玉的身份被解讀,
以及提出她的寫作是反對「感情傳遞」這種典型《紅樓夢》女性讀者性格,而且
以另一種「情之正」來控制悲痛的觀點。最後,我認為《紅樓夢》創造了一種參
與指涉。以《零香集》為背景閱讀《絳蘅秋》,我們看到文學指涉是如何具有參
與性的,即文學指涉將如何描述一個尚未被意識到的,在書中世界被勾畫的存在
實例。
Abstract
Wu Lanzheng's (1776-1806) Jiang Heng Qiu is the only dramatic sequel to
Honglou meng (Story of the Stone) to have been written by a woman. Unfinished at the
time of Wu Lanzheng’s death at the age of 30, the play was published by her husband
Yu Yongji soon afterward, in a collection entitled the Lingxiang ji (Collection of Fallen
Petals [or Scattered Fragrance]) that included poems of mourning for Wu Lanzheng as
well as requiems (jiwen) and biographies written by Yu and his friends. Wu Lanzheng’s
literary pseudonyms clearly testify that she envisioned herself as a latter-day Lin
Daiyu. In this essay, I examine the ways in which Honglou meng anticipates such later
incarnations of Lin Daiyu. I ask how Wu Lanzheng’s depiction of Lin Daiyu in Jiang
Heng Qiu can be read in the context of her own identification with Daiyu, and argue
that she writes against the notion of affective contagion that typically characterizes
female readers of Honglou meng, envisioning as an alternative an orthodox qing (qing
zhi zheng) that helps to modulate grief. Finally, I suggest that Honglou meng creates an
anticipatory referentiality. Reading Jiang Heng Qiu in the context of the Lingxiang ji,
we see how literary reference might be anticipatory, that is, how it might describe an as
yet unrealized instantiation of the presences described in the world of the book.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 戲劇研究
- ISSN
- 2070-2663
- 卷期
- 8期
- 出版
- 2011年07月
- 頁碼
- 113–138
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005772
同期目錄
- 稀見清傳奇《玉指環》考辨──兼論吳梅手稿〈玉指環傳奇序〉的發現孫書磊(Shu-lei SUN)・頁 001–020
- 晚清新知識空間裏的學生演劇與中國現代劇場的緣起鍾欣志(Joscha CHUNG)・頁 021–058
- 新詮的譯趣:「莎戲曲」《威尼斯商人》陳芳(Fang CHEN)・頁 059–090
- 數位虛擬人物形塑技術應用於戲劇服裝設計初探王怡美(Yi-meei WANG)・頁 091–112
- 吳蘭徵之《絳蘅秋》袁書菲(Sophie VOLPP)・頁 113–138
- 中國戲曲在西方歌劇中的重生與變容──試論中國戲曲元素在一九八七年大都會歌劇院《杜蘭朵》歌劇製作中的符號分析林祖誠(Tsu-cheng LIN)・頁 139–176