「宋元戲文流播大都」平議
Comments on "Song-Yuan Southern Drama (xiwen) Circulated around Dadu"
國立臺灣大學中國文學系(Department of Chinese Literature, National Taiwan University)
摘要
研究南戲的前輩學者,異口同聲主張大約南宋末或元初,或元中葉北曲雜劇
南下時,戲文大概已經流傳至大都,並有演出、編撰和大都隆福寺刻本。主此說
者皆根據清張大復《寒山堂曲譜.總目》著錄:「《金銀貓李寶閒花記》大都鄧
聚德著。業卜,字先覺,尚有《三十六瑣骨戲文》。隆福寺刻本。」這個推測起自錢南揚
先生(1899-1987)於一九八一年問世的《戲文概論》,三十年來無人置疑,影
響深遠。
本文先從宋元戲文流播浙、閩、吳、贛地區切入,以示其文獻斑斑可考,卻
無文獻證明戲文流播大都。其次論述元代戲文之盛況,北劇南戲交會以及戲文編
撰重心皆在杭州,戲文大量創作在元代晚期天曆、至正年間(1328-1368),可
知戲文難以在南宋末或元初流傳大都,並有演出。再從現存可考里居北方之戲文
作家,闡述鄧聚德雖里居大都,但不足以證明戲文流播大都;又考察北京隆福寺
建成於明代,鄧聚德戲文是明代隆福寺刊本。檢視《青樓集》著錄,唯有一則記
載專攻南戲的女伶是浙江婺州人,目前未見大都演出戲文的表演史料。以上論證
錢南揚先生之推測「理據」不足,期能彰顯積極性的學術平議。
Abstract
Scholars, who specialize in the Southern drama, xiwen, all agree with that
the Southern drama had circulated around Dadu (Khanbaliq) during the end of the
Southern Song (1127-1149) and the early Yuan dynasty (1206-1370), or when the
Northern drama was distributed to the South in the middle of the Yuan. Moreover,
the agreement elaborates that the Longfu si edition of the Southern drama was even
performed and edited in Dadu. This statement is based on the quotation “Jinshu
yingmao Li Bao xianhua ji, written by Deng Jüde in Dadu, whose occupation is a
diviner and whose courtesy name is Xianjue. He is also the author of the Longfu si
edition of Sanshiliu suogu xiwen” in Hanshantang qüpu ‘zongmu’ by Zhang Dafu
(1554-1630) of the Qing. The speculation came from the book Xiwen gailun written
in 1981 by Qian Nanyang (1899-1987). In the past thirty years, no one doubted of the
influential statement.
This paper starts from the circulation of Song-Yuan Southern drama in the areas
of Zhejiang, Fujian, Jiangsu, and Jiangxi. According to the documents and records, we,
first, cannot find evidences to prove that Ming xiwen was circulated in Dadu. Next,
the paper discusses how the Southern drama developed in the Yuan dynasty and how
the Northern and Southern drama interacted. Through the discussion, we discover that
the editing of the Southern drama mostly was in Hangzhou, and most of xiwen works
were created in the late Yuan, from Tianli to Zhizheng periods (1328-1368). Therefore,
the evidences show us that the Southern drama could be hardly circulated in Dadu
in the Southern Song or the early Yuan. In addition, the description from northern
authors, whose works are able to be traced back reliably, displays that Deng Jüde’s
residence in Dadu is unable to prove that the Southern drama was circulated in Dadu,
let alone that Deng’s work was called Longfu si edition, and the building, Longfu si,
was established in the Ming. There is only one piece in Qinglou ji that recorded that
female Southern drama specialists were the locals of Zhejiang Wuzhou, and presently
there is no performing materials of Dadu in this collection. Based on the investigation
on materials, this paper expects to make comments on Qian’s deficient in offering the
“evidences” for the circulation of the Song-Yuan Southern drama in Dadu.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 戲劇研究
- ISSN
- 2070-2663
- 卷期
- 6期
- 出版
- 2010年07月
- 頁碼
- 081–116
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005784
同期目錄
- 不得已之惡獸:來維克之泥偶怪客王寶祥(Pao-hsiang WANG)・頁 001–026
- 戲曲藝人戲神崇祀及禁忌文化析微張勇風(Yong-feng ZHANG)・頁 027–050
- 論福建民間傀儡戲的祭儀文化特質葉明生(Ming-sheng YE)・頁 051–080
- 「宋元戲文流播大都」平議李惠綿(Huei-mian LI)・頁 081–116
- 文學作家、劇本創作與舞台呈現—以楊逵戲劇論為中心邱坤良(Kun-liang CHIU)・頁 117–148
- 兩個版本的《卲江海》:戲劇史的書寫政治謝筱玫(Hsiao-mei HSIEH)・頁 149–168