兩個版本的《卲江海》:戲劇史的書寫政治
Two Versions of Shao Jiang-hai: Politics of Theatre Historiography
國立臺灣大學戲劇學系(Department of Drama and Theatre, National Taiwan University)
摘要
卲江海(1914-1980)出生於廈門,為歌仔戲發展史上的重要人物。廈門市
歌仔戲劇團演出製作的《卲江海》,敘述年輕的卲江海對歌仔戲的熱情,以及他
如何在中日戰爭期間創造出影響歌仔戲音樂的雜碎調(都馬調)。這齣戲在2002
年首演之後,即經歷多次修改。本文主要檢視它在2002/3年以及2005年間的兩個
文本(此分析文本合併劇本及演出本)在敘事上的轉變,探討歌仔戲史在這修改
的過程中,如何巧妙地被挪用,而歌仔戲的起源流布在第二版的敘事中也產生了
質變。歌仔戲身為唯一「臺灣製造」的劇種,在兩岸統獨意識形態高漲之際,大
陸的歌仔戲演出(representation)如何體現戲劇史在中國大陸的書寫政治,並反
映了中國民族主義意識形態。
Abstract
This paper discusses a contemporary play, Shao Jiang-hai, by the Xiamen
Gezaixi Troupe. Shao Jiang-hai (1914-1980), born in Xiamen, is widely considered to
be an important figure in the development of gezaixi’s music. The play tells the story
of the young Shao Jiang-hai, his passion for gezaixi, and how he created the influential
tune dumadiao during the Sino-Japanese war. The play has undergone several major
modifications since its debut in 2003. This paper particularly focuses on the changes
in its narrative from the 2002/3 version to the 2005 version. The two versions, with
seemingly similar stories, convey drastically different messages. It explores what the
process of the revisions reveals, namely, how the trajectory of gezaixi’s origin and its
cross-strait dispersal was re-delineated, from a Taiwanese origin to a mainland origin.
I examine the politics of gezaixi theatre historiography in the People’s Republic of
China at a time when the dispute over Taiwanese sovereignty dominated the cross-strait
interactions.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 戲劇研究
- ISSN
- 2070-2663
- 卷期
- 6期
- 出版
- 2010年07月
- 頁碼
- 149–168
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005786
同期目錄
- 不得已之惡獸:來維克之泥偶怪客王寶祥(Pao-hsiang WANG)・頁 001–026
- 戲曲藝人戲神崇祀及禁忌文化析微張勇風(Yong-feng ZHANG)・頁 027–050
- 論福建民間傀儡戲的祭儀文化特質葉明生(Ming-sheng YE)・頁 051–080
- 「宋元戲文流播大都」平議李惠綿(Huei-mian LI)・頁 081–116
- 文學作家、劇本創作與舞台呈現—以楊逵戲劇論為中心邱坤良(Kun-liang CHIU)・頁 117–148
- 兩個版本的《卲江海》:戲劇史的書寫政治謝筱玫(Hsiao-mei HSIEH)・頁 149–168