Adaptation of Lever Effect Theory to the New Context: A Re-Examination of the Relationship Between Agriculture Dispute Settlement and Negotiation in the WTO
Department of International Business, College of Commerce, National Chengchi University, Taipei, Taiwan
摘要
Among the theories related to dispute settlement and negotiation in the World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”), Lever Effect Theory stands out as it concentrates on analyzing the relationship between agriculture dispute settlement and multilateral agriculture negotiation. However, due to the paralysis of the Appellate Body (hereinafter “AB”) and the fragmentation of trade rulemaking, the original patterns of dispute settlement and multilateral negotiation in the WTO are facing serious challenges. This article attempts to demonstrate the limitation of agriculture dispute settlement and its impact on the Lever Effect, while accommodating the Lever Effect Theory to the AB’s paralysis. First, it argues that the respondents would take advantage of the limitation of agriculture dispute settlement and employ litigation strategies to counter the Lever Effect. Second, the Lever Effect would be hampered without a full-fledged dispute settlement system since the consistency of WTO jurisprudence and the original “checks and balances” in the WTO have been severely affected.
Abstract
Among the theories related to dispute settlement and negotiation in the World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”), Lever Effect Theory stands out as it concentrates on analyzing the relationship between agriculture dispute settlement and multilateral agriculture negotiation. However, due to the paralysis of the Appellate Body (hereinafter “AB”) and the fragmentation of trade rulemaking, the original patterns of dispute settlement and multilateral negotiation in the WTO are facing serious challenges. This article attempts to demonstrate the limitation of agriculture dispute settlement and its impact on the Lever Effect, while accommodating the Lever Effect Theory to the AB’s paralysis. First, it argues that the respondents would take advantage of the limitation of agriculture dispute settlement and employ litigation strategies to counter the Lever Effect. Second, the Lever Effect would be hampered without a full-fledged dispute settlement system since the consistency of WTO jurisprudence and the original “checks and balances” in the WTO have been severely affected.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 17卷2期
- 出版
- 2022年09月
- 頁碼
- 515–554
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000058
同期目錄
- Hong Kong’s Participation in International Dispute Settlement: Deviations from Conventional SovereigntyJulien Chaisse & Xueliang Ji・頁 287–330
- Implications of the EU’s Position on Trade Distortion for EU-China Trade Relations: From Selective Adaptation to Coordinated ComplianceChao Wang & Taixia Shen・頁 331–370
- Legalized Backsliding: The Product Under Consideration in the WTO Anti-Dumping AgreementYan Cai, Eunmi Kim, Zhuoqi Teng & Yuantao Fang・頁 371–404
- Rethinking Investment Treaties for Sustainable Development: From the “New Delhi Declaration” Principles to Modern Investment Law & PolicyXu Qian・頁 405–448
- The Presumption of Conformity for Climate Measures: Reconciling the Climate Change Regime and the WTOHyuntaik Lee・頁 449–482
- Modalities of Securing Policy Autonomy in Preferential Trade AgreementsTae Jung Park & Kil Won Lee・頁 483–514
- Adaptation of Lever Effect Theory to the New Context: A Re-Examination of the Relationship Between Agriculture Dispute Settlement and Negotiation in the WTOHui Chen・頁 515–554
- A Book Review on Petros C. Mavroidis “The WTO Dispute Settlement System: How, Why and Where?” (Edward Elgart, 2022)Yueming Yan・頁 555–564