梅蘭芳的「表情」與「京劇精神」
Mei Lanfang’s “Expression” and “the Heart of Beijing Opera”
武漢大學哲學學院
摘要
梅蘭芳並不是「京劇精神」的最高體現者,梅蘭芳也不是中國古典戲曲審美形態的終結者。梅蘭芳的戲曲美學觀是混雜的。「以梅蘭芳為代表的京劇精神」實際上是一個特定歷史時代戲曲美學思想泛西方化、泛斯坦尼化的產物。「摹仿」是西方戲劇藝術「扮演」的核心。中國戲曲藝術則是以「表現」作為「表演」的核心。同是「演」,「扮演」就是「進入角色」,「表演」則是與角色相區分。與角色相區分的根源在於中國戲曲演員的「表演」不是「表演角色」,而是「表演行當」。「表演行當」就使演員與角色之間具有了「行當」這個中介的「間離性」。正因為具有了這種「間離性」,才存在中國戲曲藝術「敍述者」、「表演者」和「評論者」集於演員一身的三重表現性,而西方戲劇藝術卻只有一重表現性:演員與角色同一。這是中國戲曲藝術與西方戲劇藝術的根本差異!
Abstract
Mei Lanfang is neither the uppermost incarnation of “the heart of Beijing opera,” nor the ultimate aesthetic model in Chinese classical drama, for his aesthetic conception of drama is eclectic. Taking Mei as the spokesman of the heart of Beijing opera in fact is the outcome of an over-emphasis on Western and Stanislavski’s theories in a specific period. “Impersonation” plays a key part of the performance in Western theater, while in traditional Chinese opera “representation” is the core of acting. The subtle difference between impersonation and representation rests on
whether the performer gets into the character. Chinese opera performer tends not to act the character, but the categorized role, which functions as a medium to distinguish the performer from the character. The very alienated nature of Chinese opera makes the performer a narrator, an actor, and a commentator as three in one. This is the most fundamental difference between Western and Chinese classical dramas.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 戲劇研究
- ISSN
- 2070-2663
- 卷期
- 2期
- 出版
- 2008年07月
- 頁碼
- 145–168
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005810
同期目錄
- 論說戲曲雅俗之推移(上)──從明嘉靖至清乾隆曾永義(Tseng Yong-Yih)・頁 001–048
- 試論中國戲劇表演的多樣性黃竹三(Huang Zhusan)・頁 049–080
- 譜歷史事義,見古人情性──論楊潮觀《吟風閣雜劇》之詠史特質與戲劇構思王璦玲(WANG Ayling)・頁 081–122
- 彈詞《倭袍傳》的流傳與諸文本岡崎由美(OKAZAKI Yumi)・頁 123–144
- 梅蘭芳的「表情」與「京劇精神」鄒元江(ZOU Yuanjiang)・頁 145–168
- 粉墨中國:性別,表演,與國族認同王德威(WANG Der-wei David)・頁 169–208
- 女人作為隱喻:《色/戒》的歷史建構與解構彭小妍(PENG Hsiao-yen)・頁 209–236
- 約翰˙佛列裘之《女人的獎賞》一劇中女人、傢俱物品、與男性階級身份之建構李慧玲(Huey-ling LEE)・頁 237–258