Why Do Civil Servants not Accept Grade Yi Ratings in Performance Appraisals? Issue Reframing and Innovation under Design Thinking
為何公務人員不接受考績乙等?設計思維下的議題重構與創新
國立政治大學公共行政學系(Department of Public Administration, National Chengchi University);東吳大學政治學系(Department of Political Science, Soochow University);國立政治大學社會科學院行政管理碩士(Master’s degree holder of Eminent Public Administrators, College of Social Sciences,
National Chengchi University)
Abstract (Chinese)
我國公務人員考績制度長期遭受甲等浮濫,而公務人員卻抗拒考列乙等之困局折磨。政府權宜地實施甲等比例設限遏止浮濫,卻沒有解決問題。本研究以設計思維途徑重新建構問題框架,將問題聚焦在:為何公務人員不接受乙等?透過針對公務人員實施的情境式問卷進行回溯性推理,以及針對臺灣、香港兩地文官與老師的作文評核實驗,本研究發現臺灣可能普遍存在對乙等之偏見,認為乙等是表現不良的符號。這是理性假設及一般人力資源管理理論無法解釋的現象。基此,政府有必要重新設計考績列等之選項,而非僅是在現有「甲乙丙丁」的框架下調整設計。
Abstract
In Taiwan, there has long been a dilemma between the inflation of Jia
grades in civil service appraisals, and civil servants’ resistance to being rated
grade Yi. The government has expediently imposed a cap on the proportion of
Jia grades, but this has not resolved the problem. This study adopts a design
thinking approach to reframe the issue, focusing on: Why do civil servants not
accept grade Yi ratings? Through the administration of a situational survey for
abductive reasoning and an essay-rating experiment involving civil servants
and teachers in Taiwan and Hong Kong, this study finds that a bias possibly
exists in Taiwan against grade Yi ratings, as it is considered to be a symbol of
poor performance. This phenomenon cannot be explained by assumptions of
rationality or any theories of human resource management. Accordingly, the
government should redesign the grading categories instead of adjusting the
existing designs of “Jia, Yi, Bing and Ding.”
Keywords
- Section
- Research Article
- Journal
- Political Science Review
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- Issue
- No. 105
- Published
- 2025-09
- Pages
- 001–038
- Record ID
- NTUEJ00005826
In this issue
- Why Do Civil Servants not Accept Grade Yi Ratings in Performance Appraisals? Issue Reframing and Innovation under Design Thinking蘇偉業(Bennis Wai-yip So);賴怡樺(Yi-hua Lai);張詠涵(Yung-han Chang)・pp. 001–038
- Can Social Mission and Commercial Interests Coexist? An Analysis of the Institutional Logics of NPO Type Social Enterprises Enterprises吳正中(Cheng-chung Wu)・pp. 039–068
- The Development, Legislation, and Future Implications of Russia’s Concept of Internet Sovereignty許菁芸(Jing-yun Hsu)・pp. 069–120