為何歐洲人對野蠻人的戰爭如此殘酷?
Why Are “Savage Wars” So Brutal?
中央研究院人文社會科學研究中心副研究員;Associate Researcher, Center for Humanities and Social Sciences, Academia Sinica.
摘要
從近代早期到20世紀初,歐洲國家和非歐洲國家發生戰爭時,歐洲軍隊對非歐洲人民非常殘酷。歐洲軍隊在這些戰爭中拒絕遵守戰爭法,沒有節制的攻擊村落、糧食、女人、老人和小孩,以及射殺戰俘。為何好幾世紀以來,歐洲人持續如此殘酷的對待非歐洲人民?過去的研究常常聚焦在個別的地區或時期,沒有做出這樣的長期觀察,也沒有解釋這件事。這篇論文採取政治理論的途徑,從四個時期的野蠻人戰爭,歸納出共同的特性,試著說明歐洲人在戰場上對待非歐洲人民的暴力是一種結構性暴力。非歐洲人民在不同時代都處在相似的結構性社會位置,讓他們必須長期面對歐洲人在戰場上不受節制的暴力。
Abstract
From the early modern period to the beginning of the 20th century, when wars occurred between European and non-European countries, the European armies often exhibited exceptional cruelty towards the non-European populations. During these conflicts, European forces frequently refused to adhere to the laws of war, indiscriminately attacking villages, food supplies, women, the elderly, children, and even executing prisoners of war without restraint. Why, for several centuries, did Europeans persist in treating non-European peoples so brutally on the battlefield? Previous research has often focused on specific regions or time periods without attempting to comprehensively explain this prolonged phenomenon across time. This paper attempts to synthesize common characteristics from four periods of “savage” warfare, seeking to explain the systemic violence perpetrated by Europeans against non-European peoples on the battlefield. Non-European populations across different eras found themselves in similar structural social positions, which exposed them to long-term, unrestrained violence from Europeans in war.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 102期
- 出版
- 2024年12月
- 頁碼
- 1–40
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005836
同期目錄
- 為何歐洲人對野蠻人的戰爭如此殘酷?陳嘉銘(Chia-ming Chen)・頁 1–40
- 客家基層官僚代表性影響政策結果之探討: 桃園市案例研究孫煒(Way Sun)・頁 41–84
- 日本自民黨總裁初選的實施與挫折:1977年至1989年吳明上(Ming-shan Wu)・頁 85–126