十九世紀末朝鮮的中國認識之背景與「脫中」問題
A Study on the Background of the Korean Perception of China and the Issue of ‘De-Sinicization’ in the Late 19th Century
國立政治大學政治學研究所博士候選人(Ph.D. Candidate, Graduate Institute of Political Science, National Chengchi University.)
摘要
十九世紀末朝鮮代韓國對「中國」的認識可分為三:「作為地區霸權的中國」(清朝)、「作為政權正當性的基礎之中國」(明朝)、以及「作為文化體系的中國」(小中華意識)。甲午戰爭結束後,朝鮮雖然「脫離清朝的朝貢體系」,卻脫離不了明朝的遺產與小中華意識。即,在受到文明論影響之下,朝鮮社會對於「脫中」問題上引起分歧。首先,激進開化派依據進化論的文明觀念,正面質疑華夷觀念,並沒有把清朝與「作為文化體系的中國」之間劃清界線,並將清朝(以及中國文化)視為阻礙朝鮮文明開化之傳統象徵,從而主張全面脫離「中國」。其次,穩健開化派在西方文明和東洋文明的價值觀之間儘量保持中立,在「小中華意識」的歷史經驗上添加了「文明論」,從而指出「東洋」概念。也就是說,當代朝鮮儒教菁英將中華傳統文明和西方近代文明劃等號,從而主張保存中華文明的朝鮮能與近代西方文明國並肩而立。在此立基點上,朝鮮改國號為「大韓帝國」,毫無猶豫地採用中國傳統象徵符號,以展現自主獨立國家的姿態。這些認識及思路,在今日仍有助於我們對當代問題,進行深刻而有新意的省思。作者希望透過本研究的成果,讓學界可以從不同的角度,再一次認識到儒教思想在韓半島的發展軌跡。
Abstract
The Korean perception of China in the Late 19th century can be divided into three categories. The first is ‘China as a regional hegemon.’ The second is China as the basis of the legitimacy of political power. The third is ‘China as a cultural system.’ After the Sino-Japanese War, Korea tried to modernize itself as it escaped from the China-centered tributary system, and it externally became an independent nation. However, there were different opinions on the issue of the ‘de-chinization’ process among the Korean society of the age, and how they accepted the civilizational discourse. Firstly, the radical reformists argued for total and complete de-chinization, pointing out that they identified China as a regional hegemon as being tied to China as a cultural system, and they argued that these factors disturbed Korean civilization and enlightenment. On the contrary, the Confucian elites of the moderate reformists completely separated the China that is a regional hegemon from the China that is the cultural system, and they argued that Chinese traditional civilization and Western civilization belong to a universal civilization. Furthermore, the Joseon Dynasty (朝鮮王朝) changed the name of the country to the Korean Empire (大韓帝國) and tried to show that it’s a universal civilized country and an independent nation internally and externally based on this awareness. This article will provide a deeper understanding of the Korean perception of China and the de-chinization of issues in the 19th century.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 82期
- 出版
- 2019年12月
- 頁碼
- 39–80
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005911
同期目錄
- 以「事天」為本之治理思想:明末儒者安世鳳《尊孔錄》之研究林峻煒(Chun-wei Lin)・頁 1–38
- 十九世紀末朝鮮的中國認識之背景與「脫中」問題朴炳培(Byungbae Park)・頁 39–80
- 總統道歉的語言學:「蔡英文總統代表政府向原住民族道歉文」的政治語言學分析黃之棟(Morgan Chih-tung Huang);朱容萱(Rong-xuan Chu)・頁 81–114
- 民進黨為何攻不下農會?以2017年臺中市潭子區、大雅區農會選舉為例陳麗雅(Li-ya Chen);王業立(Yeh-lih Wang)・頁 115–152
- APEC組織運作建制化的發展:以「半拘束性決議」的出現與「秘書處強化」為例周子欽(Tzu-chin Chou)・頁 153–186
- APEC的中美領導權之爭:以亞太自貿區議題為例廖小娟(Hsiao-chuan Liao)・頁 187–226