論梁啟超「國民」概念的兩面性:以Bluntschli國家學說作為背景的考
The Two Faces of Liang Qichao’s Concept of “Volk”
國立中山大學政治學研究所(Institute of Political Science, National Sun Yat-sen University)
;文化大學政治系(Department of Political Science, Chinese Culture University)
摘要
梁啟超的政治思想在1903年赴美之後出現巨大的轉變。在此前,梁啟超比較傾向於民權和政治體系的變動;在之後則趨於保守、反對共和革命。而無論是在思想轉變之前或之後,其論述都是以「國民」這一間接從Bluntschli繼受而來的概念為核心。
本文試圖藉由脈絡主義的研究方法來指出,梁啟超是基於當時的情勢和不同的立場,取其所需的部分來使用Bluntschli的國民概念。而之所以他能夠如此使用此一概念,則是因為這一概念源於19世紀的德國國家學。後者的特點是,其本質為人民主權與君主主權之爭的妥協方案,因此具有兩面性,亦即同時包含了有利於民權的部分亦具有有利於君主制的部分。
Abstract
Liang Qichao’s political thought took a dramatic turn after his travels to the United States in 1903. Previously, Liang had tended to emphasize the importance of political rights and the transformation of the political system. Later, his attitude became more conservative, and he began to stand against the Republican revolution. What remains constant throughout his writings, however, is the core concept of the “people” (Volk), which Liang indirectly took from Bluntschli.
Using the contextualist method, this article attempts to point out that Liang merely took the parts of Bluntschli’s concept of Volk which served his purposes well, depending upon the situation and political goal. It was possible for him to use the term for opposing purposes as it originated from 19th century German political theory, which was essentially shaped by political compromise between the ruler and popular sovereignty. It, therefore, had a double meaning, which contained arguments both in favor of civil liberties and in support of the persistence of the monarchy.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 79期
- 出版
- 2019年03月
- 頁碼
- 1–40
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005925
同期目錄
- 論梁啟超「國民」概念的兩面性:以Bluntschli國家學說作為背景的考楊尚儒(Shang-ju Yang);林奕蒼(Yi-tsang Lin)・頁 1–40
- 論宗教脈絡在理解霍布斯政治義務理論中的角色:以「自由的恰當意涵」為例周家瑜(Chia-yu Chou)・頁 41–68
- 帶祖先回家的法律?美國原住民族墓葬保護暨返還法的困境與啟示黃之棟(Chih-tung Huang)・頁 69–98