釋憲趨勢與半總統制的制度韌性
Constitutional Jurisprudence and Institutional Resilience of Taiwanese Semi-Presidentialism
臺灣大學政治學系暨公共事務研究所教授、中央研究院法律學研究所合聘研究員(Professor of Department of Political Science & Graduate Institute of Public Affairs, National Taiwan University; Research Fellow (Joint Appointment) of Institutum Iurisprudentiae, Academia Sinica)
摘要
半總統制表面上是一個具有彈性的制度,因為它可以在總統制與議會內閣制間擺盪換軌,故半總統制的制度韌性似乎應該比其他兩制都強。但也正是因其制度彈性所留下的解釋空間,更容易引發爭議。違憲審查制度因為可以化解解釋爭議,所以也就能強化制度韌性。我國違憲審查制度已經運作近70年,但自1997年我國進入半總統制後,其逐漸失去化解爭議,強化制度韌性的功能。本文嘗試分析其原因,並提出改革建議。
Abstract
On the surface, semi-presidentialism creates a more flexible regime as it
may switch between presidentialism and parliamentarism whenever it deems
necessary. It seems that the institutional resilience of semi-presidentialial
system is better than that of other political layouts. However, institutional
flexibility of semi-presidentialism could also create rooms for controversy.
Fortunately, constitutional judicial review, in general, could strengthen the
resilience of semi-presidentialism by performing its function of textual
interpretation to solve political conflicts. Nonetheless, after being in place for
nearly seventy years and particularly after the constitutional reform in 1997,
the constitutional judicial review in the ROC has lost bit by bit its function of
resolving political conflicts . The aim of this article is to analyze the reasons of
its decline and to put forward some proposals for future reform.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 72期
- 出版
- 2017年06月
- 頁碼
- 001–056
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005952
同期目錄
- 釋憲趨勢與半總統制的制度韌性陳淳文(Chwen-wen Chen)・頁 001–056
- 日本郵政事業的民營化˙自由化與普及服務林淑馨(Shu-hsin Lin)・頁 057–090
- 電影作為國際關係教學文本與研究工具之後社理論思辯莫大華(Ta-hua Mo)・頁 091–120
- 歐美跨大西洋貿易及投資夥伴協定之興起與挑戰李貴英(Catherine Li)・頁 121–148