從組閣爭議論我國憲政體制 的定位與走向
Exploring the Positioning of Taiwan’s Constitutional System in Terms of the Controversy over Cabinet Formation
中國文化大學行政管理學系、國立臺灣大學政治學系(Department of Public Administration and Management, Chinese Culture University.、Department of Political Science, National Taiwan University.)
摘要
我國憲政體制究竟是屬於偏內閣制還是偏總統制的半總統制,純粹從憲法條文來觀察並不容易得到明確的答案。這是因為相較於世界上其他半總統制國家的憲法,我國憲法對於憲政體制的規範密度明顯較低,致使學者對於我國憲政體制的內涵各有不同的法理詮釋。這些詮釋觀點的關鍵差異,主要是對於我國總統憲法權力的看法不同,尤其是對於總統任命閣揆的權力有不同見解。本文以我國總統任命閣揆的憲法權力為焦點,探討我國憲政體制定位的法理爭議;並以總統與國會不一致時的組閣爭議為主要線索,探討我國憲政體制的實際定位與走向。本文認為,儘管我國憲政體制的定位在法理上頗有爭議,但從過去總統與國會多數不一致與歷次政黨輪替交接期的實際組閣情況來看,幾乎已完全確立我國憲政體制是偏總統制的半總統制。
Abstract
Whether Taiwan’s constitutional system, semi-presidentialism, is considered to be parliamentarism-oriented or presidentialism-oriented can not be easily judged merely based on the constitution. Compared to the constitutions of other countries that adopt semi-presidentialism, Taiwan’s constitution apparently has less specifications regarding the constitutional system, and this is the reason why there are many different legal interpretations on Taiwan’s constitutional system. The key factor that causes the difference among these interpretations is the understanding of the president’s constitutional powers, especially the power to appoint the premier. Focusing on the president’s power to appoint the premier, this paper tries to explore the legal dispute surrounding Taiwan’s constitutional system, and to discover its actual position and the trend behind by investigating the controversy of cabinet formation under the circumstances when the president and the parliament disagree with each other. The finding is that, legally speaking, the position of Taiwan’s constitutional system is rather debatable, but it is almost certain that Taiwan’s constitutional system is semi-presidentialism and it is presidentialism-oriented according to the past few incidents of actual cabinet formation under the circumstances that the president and the parliament disagreed with each other.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 70期
- 出版
- 2016年12月
- 頁碼
- 085–120
- 編號
- NTUEJ00005962
同期目錄
- 王夫之治理思想三論:以《老子衍》與《張子正蒙注》為核心林俊宏(Chun-hung Lin)・頁 001–044
- 歐洲國家監察制度獨立性的實證分析: 兼論與民主品質的關係陳澤鑫、汪林玲(Tse-hsin Chen、Lin-ling Uang)・頁 045–084
- 從組閣爭議論我國憲政體制 的定位與走向蘇子喬、王業立(Tzu-chiao Su、Yeh-lih Wang)・頁 085–120
- 解析跨大西洋貿易 與投資夥伴協議(TTIP): 理想與現實的可能矛盾賴昀辰(Yun-chen Lai)・頁 121–158
- 中國文化與中國對外行為: 「興滅繼絕」理念與朝鮮「壬辰倭亂」楊仕樂(Shih-yueh Yang)・頁 159–196