民主必然促進人權?東南亞人權保障之實證分析
Can Democracy Promote Human Rights?An Empirical Analysis of Southeast Asia: 1981-2008
中央研究院法律學研究所博士後研究(Postdoctoral Researcher, Institutum Iurisprudentiae, Academia Sinica (IIAS).
摘要
1993年聯合國世界人權會議所通過的〈維也納宣言和行動綱領〉(Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action)指出,民主、發展、以及尊重人權和基本自由之間有著相互依賴的彼此強化的關係。然而,這樣的主張究竟是有其實存的基礎支持?抑或僅為規範性理想的陳述?本文主要的目的,在於從實證的視角檢視東南亞地區自1980年代以來的人權政治實踐,分析影響東南亞地區人身自由權保障的內外因素。研究發現,國內因素較國際因素更能夠解釋東南亞地區人權保障的行為模式。常見的「民主-人權」命題並非單一絕對,對於不同類型的人身自由權,民主的抑制效果並不盡相同。甚至在劇烈的政治變遷過程中,酷刑虐待出現的機率反而上升,這意味著在面臨國際人權的理念壓力時,不同的壓制策略之間可能出現彼此替代的效果。
Abstract
The 1990s witnessed the rise of the Asian values debate as governments in Southeast Asia rejected the idea of universal human rights. Nevertheless, critical developments in human rights promotion and protection have occurred in the last decade across countries in the region. This article offers an empirical analysis of human rights politics in Southeast Asia from 1981 to 2008. With a focus on personal integrity rights, it is found that domestic-level factors are more critical than external forces in understanding the actual level of rights protection in Southeast Asian countries. Human rights treaty ratification and foreign aid fail to facilitate rights protection. Additionally, the constraining effect of democracy on human rights violation is not uniform. The results suggest that the relationship between democracy and human rights varies from one type of personal integrity rights to another, and implies the substitutability of repressive strategies employed by state authority toward its people.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 56期
- 出版
- 2013年06月
- 頁碼
- 091–118
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006021
同期目錄
- 用過核燃料之國際多邊化管控趨勢:兼論我國處理用過核燃料策略的契機曾雅真(Yea-jen Tseng)・頁 001–038
- 魯曼觀察理論與政治論述解讀黃鉦堤(Jeng-ti Huang)・頁 039–090
- 民主必然促進人權?東南亞人權保障之實證分析顏永銘(Yung-ming Yen)・頁 091–118
- 臺北市與高雄市住宅財產稅之比較:兼論兩市財稅努力之差異王宏文(Hong-wung Wang);曾彥閔( Yan-min Zeng)・頁 119–156