蘇轍《老子解》中的思想三論
Three Theses on the Philosophy of Three Theses on the Philosophy of Ruling in Su Che’s Laozi Jie Ruling in Su Che’s Laozi Jie
國立台灣大學政治學系(Department of Political Science, National Taiwan University.)
摘要
經典、思想與現實政治的對話,從來不是單一與因果式的路徑,尤其是不同學術集團、思想變動的轉折處以及不同的政治格局三個條件,同時並存且相互激盪時。蘇轍的《老子解》呈現出結合儒道釋三家基本內蘊的書寫形式,正是北宋思想轉折的一個產物,在表面以儒學為基準的基調之下,這種透過精英獨特且再造傳統的特有注解文本,一定程度地接收了重玄思想關於儒道釋思想轉詮的成果,並且,因應政治場域中的緊張對立,開創了一個兼涉現實政治與信仰詮釋的思維,這使得在現實政治的關懷之外,同時也增加了往宗教國度的移動向量。本文企圖透過文本的閱讀與解析,從中透顯出蘇轍的《老子解》的思想(包括了道之論、性之論與治理之論)以及隠藏在思想背後的一些時代性與特色。而文學傳統、反映古人之道的「文」以及普世的價值,這三個議題在宋初的古文運動、注解經典的活動以及道學作為普世價值的形塑運動中,很有層次地展現,構成了所謂的「國家與士紳雙重支持下的文明擴張」,我們在蘇轍的《老子解》中也讀到了這樣的趨勢。
Abstract
This article deals with the internal philosophicalcontext of Su Che’s (蘇轍)
Laozi Jie (老子解). My thesis argues that Taoist thought, and in particular the
thought of Laozi, has its own axial development when treated as an intellectual
community which interacts with other intellectual or religious communities such as
Taoism,Buddhism and Confucianism. Thesefour communities not only compete
with each other in political domain but also in other spheres. This article examines
the position of Laozi Jiein the intellectual history of the Northern Song Dynasty and
discusses the epistemological with ontological understandings found in the text. It
argues that the “revivification of nature” (復性) is central to Su Che’s philosophy.
The article also deals with the issue of hierarchal ranking of political and religious
affairs. When political discourses interacted with or intervened in religious affairs,
new forms of thinking emerged. Laozi Jieconveys the internal essence of political discourses of Taoism, Taoist
religion, Buddhism and Song-Ming Confucianism (宋明儒學). Through textual
analysis, the internal thought of Laoziand several commentaries ofLaozireveal
themselves. Latent connectionsbetween the Mysticism School, Double Negation
School and Song-Ming Confucianism also appear. The content ofthis text lies
hidden and latent, and is not only philosophical but also intellectual and political in
nature. It forms a central part of the process ofstate formation and the rebuilding of
public civilization in the Northern Song Dynasty.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 49期
- 出版
- 2011年09月
- 頁碼
- 033–074
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006049
同期目錄
- 建構都會多元中心的治理:反思都市發展不對稱與民主赤字問題趙永茂(Yung-mau Chao);陳銘顯(Ming-hsien Chen);王皓平(Hao-ping Wang)・頁 001–032
- 蘇轍《老子解》中的思想三論林俊宏(Chun-hung Lin)・頁 033–074
- 國際關係實用建構主義理論的知識論分析莫大華(Ta-hua Mo)・頁 075–124
- 非營利組織績效評量指標之建構彭錦鵬(Thomas Ching-peng Peng);江瑞祥(Ri-sharng Chiang);許耿銘(Keng-ming Hsu)・頁 125–160
- 台灣婦運與世代價值差異楊婉瑩(Wan-ying Yang)・頁 161–195