總理總統制與政治穩定:以烏克蘭、羅馬尼亞為例
Premier-Presidentialism and Political Stability: Comparing Romania with Ukraine
國立中正大學政治系副教授(Associate Professor, Department of Political Science, National Chung Cheng University.);國立政治大學政治系博士班學生(Doctoral Student, Department of Political Science, National Chengchi University.)
摘要
比較憲政工程的傳統智慧認為半總統制的次類型總理總統制比另一次類型總統國會制運作更為穩定,並且援引法國或葡萄牙等總理總統制國家運作成功的個案作為相關的佐證。然而,一些總理總統制的新興民主國家,其運作上卻出現政治不穩定的現象。本文的目的在於探究為何這些總理總統制國家會出現不穩定的原因和模式以及透過這些反面個案(negative cases)來搜尋總理總統制成功運作的關鍵因素。
Abstract
The conventional wisdom on comparative constitutional engineering argues, on the basis of the successful experiences of France and Portugal, that the operation of premier-presidentialism (one subtype of semi-presidentialism) has been more stable than the operation of president-parliamentarism (the other subtype of semi-presidentialism). However, some newly democratized countries which have chosen premier-presidentialism have witnessed political instability. This paper aims to explore why these countries have suffered from political instability and to identify the crucial factors which facilitate the democratic workability of premier-presidentialism, by way of analyzing these negative cases.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 研究論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 47期
- 出版
- 2011年03月
- 頁碼
- 065–106
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006059
同期目錄
- 半總統制:全球發展與研究議程吳玉山(Yu-Shan Wu)・頁 001–032
- 半總統制下行政體系二元化之內涵沈有忠(Yu-chung Shen)・頁 033–064
- 總理總統制與政治穩定:以烏克蘭、羅馬尼亞為例蔡榮祥(Jung-hsiang Tsai);石鵬翔(Peng-hsiang Shih)・頁 065–106
- 一致政府下的內閣穩定:比較二○○八年總統大選之後的俄羅斯與台灣李鳳玉(Feng-yu Lee);藍夢荷(Meng-ho Lan)・頁 107–142
- 二○○八年後梅-普架構下俄羅斯半總統制的檢視趙竹成(Zhu-cheng Zhao)・頁 143–174