一致政府下的內閣穩定:比較二○○八年總統大選之後的俄羅斯與台灣
Cabinet Stability Under Unified Government: The Cases of Russia and Taiwan After the 2008 Presidential Elections
臺灣大學政治系助理教授( Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, National Taiwan University.);臺灣大學政治系研究生(Graduate Student, Department of Political Science, National Taiwan University.)
摘要
過去的研究認為在總理總統制的運作當中,國會的政黨組成情況對於政治穩定有關鍵性的影響,同時也論證如果總統黨能夠進入國會的多數執政聯盟,對於政治穩定會有正面的幫助。本文針對東歐的總理總統制國家烏克蘭、羅馬尼亞之憲政運作進行分析,探討國會的政黨組成情況對於政治穩定的影響。本文觀察兩個案例後發現,即使總統黨進入多數的執政聯盟後,還必須觀察總統黨在多數聯盟內部是否具有主導地位才能進一步判斷國會的政黨組成情況對於政治穩定的影響。如果總統黨無法在執政聯盟內部取得領導的地位,而是由總理黨取得主導地位,則總統權力可能會受到較大的制約,容易引發總統和總理之間的衝突,政治運作較為不穩定。反之,當總統黨能主導執政聯盟,則總統權力受到制約的情況較小,總統與總理較不易發生衝突,政治運作較為穩定。
Abstract
Past research claims that the constellation of political parties in the parliament is the key factor affecting political stability and also suggests that if the president’s party is included in the ruling coalition, then it can substantially contribute to the political stability of premier-presidentialism. After delving into the cases of Romania and Ukraine, this paper further argues that not only do we need to observe whether the president’s party is in the coalition, but we also need to examine whether the president’s party has a dominant position in the coalition. If the prime minister’s party, rather than the president’s party, takes the helm in the coalition, presidential power and authority may be constrained, thereby leading to the clashes between the president and prime minister and sometimes to serious political instability. In contrast, when the president’s party leads the coalition, conflicts between the president and prime minister are less likely, leading to greater political stability.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 研究論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 47期
- 出版
- 2011年03月
- 頁碼
- 107–142
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006060
同期目錄
- 半總統制:全球發展與研究議程吳玉山(Yu-Shan Wu)・頁 001–032
- 半總統制下行政體系二元化之內涵沈有忠(Yu-chung Shen)・頁 033–064
- 總理總統制與政治穩定:以烏克蘭、羅馬尼亞為例蔡榮祥(Jung-hsiang Tsai);石鵬翔(Peng-hsiang Shih)・頁 065–106
- 一致政府下的內閣穩定:比較二○○八年總統大選之後的俄羅斯與台灣李鳳玉(Feng-yu Lee);藍夢荷(Meng-ho Lan)・頁 107–142
- 二○○八年後梅-普架構下俄羅斯半總統制的檢視趙竹成(Zhu-cheng Zhao)・頁 143–174