民主的脆弱性與鞏固:一個敗者同意的視角
Democratic Fragility and Consolidation: A Perspective of Losers’ Consent
中央研究院政治學研究所(Institute of Political Science, Academia Sinica)
摘要
轉型期的新興民主國家往往受到來自反對勢力的挑戰,而無法持續維繫穩定的民主政體終告失敗,甚而解體並回歸威權統治。筆者發現傳統政治學研究習於從「多數」的角度觀察民主進程而存在著難以突破的盲點,且無法解決最為迫切的民主鞏固問題。為解決這些最根本的問題,筆者主張從「少數同意」的視角出發,針對新興民主國家在民主締造至鞏固的歷程中,指出最為必要解決的課題:少數與多數的衝突。筆者認為解決少數與多數之間的衝突達成民主鞏固的方法有四個:開放性的競爭環境、建立可為少數接受的制度化官僚機制、擴大公共參與及尋求國際組織協助。
Abstract
Due to challenges from political opposition, some fledgling democracies cannot maintain democratic stability and eventually breakdown. This paper finds that because students of democratization tend to rest their theories on a majority perspective, they cannot solve the substantive deadlock faced by new democracies: the conflicts between the majority and minority. To address this problem and to provide useful suggestions for new democracies, this paper suggests a perspective of minority consent and puts forward four suggestions for preventing majorityminority conflicts and consolidating developing democracies: expanding the level of political competition, establishing bureaucratic independence and autonomy, expanding public participation, and requesting assistance from international organizations.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 研究論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 42期
- 出版
- 2009年12月
- 頁碼
- 043–084
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006079
同期目錄
- 食品政治:「誰」左右了國際食品安全的標準?譚偉恩(Wei-En Tan);蔡育岱(Yu-Tai Ts’ai)・頁 001–042
- 民主的脆弱性與鞏固:一個敗者同意的視角張傳賢(Alex Chuan-Hsien Chang)・頁 043–084
- 性別、環境與研究發展:全球氣候變化議題的性別觀點施奕任(Yi-Jen Shih)・頁 085–136
- 科技評估與民主:韓國科技評估組織之法制與程序劉華美(Hwa-Meei, Liou)・頁 137–168