現任者聲譽對負面競選廣告效果之影響
The Incumbent's Reputation and the Effects of Negative Campaign Advertisement
國立臺灣大學商學研究所(Graduate Institute of Business Administration, National Taiwan University)
摘要
本研究旨在探討現任者的聲譽高/低以及理性/感性訴求型態,對於負面競選廣告的效果究竟有何影響。作者以實驗設計的方式,分別從廣告發起者是現任者或是挑戰者的不同面向切入,進行了兩個實驗,研究結果發現:當負面廣告的發起人是現任者時,聲譽高的現任者比較不適合使用負面攻擊,因爲如此一來,對於自己造成的傷害較大,其若使用感性訴求,則可以使傷害減少,而聲譽低的現任者,若發起負面攻擊,則不論是使用理性或是感性訴求,並沒有顯著差異的效果;當負面廣告的發起人是挑戰者時,若其攻擊聲譽高的現任者,會對自己造成較大的傷害,然而,若攻擊聲譽低的,則會產生同情效應,使選民更加支持被攻擊者,因上述兩種情況都產生於己不利的結果,故挑戰者不適合使用負面競選廣告,若是執意使用,則以使用理性訴求爲佳。
Abstract
Negative campaign ads have become an indispensable technique in modern day elections. Particularly for one-to-one elections, it is very common to see various ads attacking the other party, broadcast throughout the media. Although much research has been undertaken examining the effects of negative ads, the results are inconclusive and there are still many important issues worthy of further exploration. This paper investigates the effects of these ads on the incumbent's reputation. It also looks at which types of ads are important but were previously neglected by previous empirical research into negative campaign advertising. Based on the expectancy disconfirmation model and the theory of persuasive knowledge, we infer the hypotheses and conduct two experiments to explore the effects of these variables under different contexts: the ad sponsor being the incumbent or the challenger. Results indicate that when the sponsor is the incumbent, it is not beneficial for the incumbent to use attacking ads, as this leads to an increase in self imposed damage to reputation and a decrease in voters' voting intention to a greater degree than for those with lower reputation. Using emotional appeals would decrease the amount of damage done. As for low reputation incumbents, appealing types of advertisement do not make a significant difference to voter responses. When the ad sponsor was the challenger, attacking the high-reputation incumbent generated boomerang effect, causing greater damage to the sponsor, whilst attacking the low-reputation one would generate the victimsyndrome effect, improving voters' target evaluation, attitude, and voting intention toward the target. Thus it is not suitable for the challenger to use negative campaign ads. If he still decides to go with negative ads, rational appeals are more beneficial for him. Besides deceasing potential for self-inflicted damage, rational appeals would either make voters feel more unfavorable towards the targeted candidate or would maintain voters' political participation intent, depending on the incumbent's reputation. The implications of these and other findings are discussed.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 研究論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 38期
- 出版
- 2008年12月
- 頁碼
- 113–154
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006097
同期目錄
- 尋找國際關係的結構圖閻嘯平(Hsiao-Ping Yen)・頁 001–034
- 中共領導人權力消長在黨報新聞照片上的呈現寇健文(Chien-Wen Kou);梁書瑗(Shu-Yuan Liang)・頁 035–070
- 日本政府與殖民統治初期台灣的幣制改革李世暉(Shih-Hui Li)・頁 071–112
- 現任者聲譽對負面競選廣告效果之影響練乃華(Nai-Hwa Lien);周軒逸(Hsuan-Yi Chou)・頁 113–154