意圖與意義-論Quentin Skinner意義理論中的一些問題
Intention and Meaning-On Some Questions in Quentin Skinner's Theory of Meaning
中國文化大學政治學系(Department of Political Science, Chinese Culture University)
摘要
在政治思想史的研究中,Quentin Skinner被視為所謂「劍橋學派」的領袖人物之一。其理論的特點在於Skinner提出了一種特別的意義理論:歷史文獻所負載的意義不僅是其文字所敘述的意義,更重要的是其作者述作時的意圖。而要正確地理解與恢復作者的意圖,必須要正確地掌握作者寫作時的脈絡。然而若干學者反對這樣的方法,認為Skinner過度強調作者意圖對於文本意義的影響。本文一方面將試圖釐清這些批評的論點,另一方面要藉由語言哲學家John Searle的理論,說明意義的來源乃是來自反應人類心靈的心理狀態,因此文本的意義不只由字面上的語意、而是由語意與心靈狀態的一致性所決定。因此對於Skinner理論的批評不夠充分。
Abstract
Quentin Skinner, the leading figure of the so-called 'Cambridge School', has developed a unique methodology for studying the history of political thought. One tenet in his theory is that the meaning of a text depends more heavily on the author's intention in writing than on the semantic level. Some academics have criticised Skinner's theory for putting too much emphasis on the author's intention than on the text itself. In addition to spelling out these criticisms, this article argues that by applying John Searle's theory (contending that the source of meaning comes from language's capacity to represent human Intentional states), the meaning of a text rests on both the agreement of the semantic level and also on the author's Intentional states. Thus it can be concluded that Skinner's argument is more convincing than those criticisms against him.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 研究論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 33期
- 出版
- 2007年09月
- 頁碼
- 083–116
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006119
同期目錄
- 結構網絡的分析及其脈絡馬財專(Tsai-Chuan Ma)・頁 001–042
- 鐵路地下化預算規劃之交易成本政治學分析曾偉豪(Wei-Hao Tseng)・頁 043–082
- 意圖與意義-論Quentin Skinner意義理論中的一些問題梁裕康(Yu-Kang Liang)・頁 083–116
- 攻守理論的實證檢驗:案例比較研究1914~1973楊仕樂(Shih-Yueh Yang)・頁 117–150
- 現代化典範與中共民主前景:第四條道路楊穎超(Ying-Chao Yang)・頁 151–192