攻守理論的實證檢驗:案例比較研究1914~1973
Empirical Testing of the Offense-Defense Theory: A Comparative Study 1914-1973
國立政治大學外交學系(Department of Diplomacy, National Chengchi University)
摘要
本文的研究目的是檢驗「科技」與「地理」因素對於「攻守平衡」變異的影響。本文首先將簡述「攻守理論」中解釋「攻守平衡」變異的主要因果邏輯,說明科技與地理因素如何影響攻守平衡,從此提出推論並介紹各項概念的定義與衡量指標,隨後進行控制比較的實證檢驗。在實證檢驗中,本文將先分別討論選定案例間,其科技的變化以及地理環境的差異,並依此推論攻守平衡狀態的變動,隨後再以兩次大戰與第三、第四次中東戰爭中,所選定案例的作戰記錄為衡量攻守平衡的依據進行比對,藉此檢驗科技與地理因素對攻守平衡變異的解釋力。本文發現,案例的比較研究大致上均支持本文的推論,科技與地理因素對攻守平衡的變異,是具有一定的解釋力。
Abstract
The objective of this article is to investigate the impacts of "technology" and "geography" on the variance of "offense-defense balance." This article starts by summarizing the main causal logic: how "technology" and "geography" affect the "Offense-defense Balance." It then offers an operational definition and measuring parameter for each of these concepts and thereafter constructs the causal hypotheses between "technology," "geography," and "offense-defense balance." In total 16 cases have been selected for analysis within three following periods: the First World War (1914-1918), the Second World War (1939-1945), and the Six Day War/Yom Kippur War (1967-1973). In conclusion, a controlled comparison study is conducted to test the hypotheses. This results in rather positive results being found in support of the hypotheses; in other words showing that military technology and geography do indeed exert considerable explanatory power on the variance of "offense-defense balance."
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 研究論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 33期
- 出版
- 2007年09月
- 頁碼
- 117–150
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006120
同期目錄
- 結構網絡的分析及其脈絡馬財專(Tsai-Chuan Ma)・頁 001–042
- 鐵路地下化預算規劃之交易成本政治學分析曾偉豪(Wei-Hao Tseng)・頁 043–082
- 意圖與意義-論Quentin Skinner意義理論中的一些問題梁裕康(Yu-Kang Liang)・頁 083–116
- 攻守理論的實證檢驗:案例比較研究1914~1973楊仕樂(Shih-Yueh Yang)・頁 117–150
- 現代化典範與中共民主前景:第四條道路楊穎超(Ying-Chao Yang)・頁 151–192