政府主管如何看待績效不佳員工台灣與美國之比較分析
How Public Managers Manage Their Poor Performers: A Comparison and Analysis of Taiwan and the United States
東吳大學政治學系(Department of Political Science, Soochow University)
摘要
政府在與公務員的勞資關係中,傳統上一向扮演提供永業保障,多激勵少懲處的模範雇主角色,對於績效表現未達應有標準的員工,甚少採取積極的處理。但隨著政府治理普遍遭遇資源有限,公民對政府績效課責要求升高,政府遂面臨必須積極提昇績效的現實壓力。因此,對於績效不佳員工的積極有效處理,就成為許多政府績效改革的重要課題之一。本文重點,就在於分析與比較,台灣與美國兩個國家的政府主管,如何看待與處理績效不佳員工,並從中比較異同之處。研究發現,台灣與美國政府主管,僅在少數議題呈現不同觀點,在多數議題則呈現頗為相似的態度與行為。本文最後則提出研究發現意涵討論與政策建議。
Abstract
Based on the traditional expectation that governments should be exemplary employers, most governments initiate many protective personnel policies and laws to manage their employees. Those protective policies include permanent career opportunities, job security and motivational mechanisms. At the same time, governments don't have many effective programs to manage their poor performers. Faced with high performance requirements from the public, governments can no longer passively manage their poor performers. Governments need to strengthen management of poor performers in the public sector more than ever before. This paper attempts to analyze and compare the attitudes of public managers towards poor performers in Taiwan and United States. Through literature review and secondary analysis, it is found that public managers of the two governments have similar attitudes on this topic. The remainder of this paper therefore discusses two issues. Firstly, implications of the study findings. Secondly, this paper articulates some suggestions to the Taiwan government.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 研究論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 32期
- 出版
- 2007年06月
- 頁碼
- 109–144
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006125
同期目錄
- 文化多元社會中的領導葛永光・頁 001–030
- 英國風的《君王論》莎士比亞《亨利四世》(上、下)為君之道的探討陳思賢(Sy-Shyan Chen)・頁 031–070
- 日本非政府組織與政府之外交協力兼論外務省的支援措施與對我國之啟示林淑馨(Shu-Hsin Lin)・頁 071–108
- 政府主管如何看待績效不佳員工台灣與美國之比較分析蔡秀涓(Hsiu-Chuan Tsai)・頁 109–144
- 成玄英的重玄思想與政治論述-以《南華真經注疏》為核心林俊宏(Chun-Hung Lin)・頁 145–202