拉克勞(Ernesto Laclau)霸權理論中的敵對與異質性
Antagonism and Heterogeneity in Ernesto Laclau's Hegemony Theory
東吳大學政治系(Department of Political Science, Soochow University)
摘要
本文試圖指出,正是由於拉克勞與慕芙堅持建立霸權的必要性,所以即便兩位作者一再強調霸權終極不完滿的特性,其對於「離散」(dispersion)與「異質性」(heterogeneity)的理解,仍無可避免地從結構角度出發,並視之為結構的匱乏或不足。本文試圖檢視拉克勞從《霸權與社會主義策略》出版之後一系列的理論深化與修正,說明不論是早期詮釋的「離散中的規律」或是晚近的「異質性」都是基於某個特定的政治存有論的立場上出發加以理解的。本文認為,拉克勞的立場,雖然經歷了幾次修正,但並未如某些論者所言產生了根本性的改變,基本上仍是相當連貫的。而其連貫性便是建立在對於離散與異質性的特定理解上,並持續對於霸權理論延伸出來的政治想像產生了極為根本的影響。
Abstract
Despite the fact that dispersion / heterogeneity is not thoroughly discussed in Laclau and Mouffe's earlier work on hegemony, it does indeed play a significant role. I would contend that hegemony theory is, from the outset, constructed in the particular way in which dispersion/heterogeneity is theorized. This paper attempts to demonstrate that although Laclau and Mouffe have constantly emphasized the ultimate impossibility of closure, their insistence on the necessity of antagonism and hegemonic formation has generated a seemingly inevitable effect: that dispersion/heterogeneity can only be perceived from the perspective of structure/system and deemed as its lack or deficiency. The first part of this paper discusses the notion of 'regularity of dispersion'. This will then be followed by an explication of categories of 'antagonism' and 'dislocation' and how they are related to Laclau's understanding of dispersion/heterogeneity. The third part focuses on the reformulation of the category of heterogeneity in Laclau's latest work, and will provide a preliminary reflection on its theoretical as well as political consequences.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 研究論文
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 30期
- 出版
- 2006年12月
- 頁碼
- 097–130
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006135
同期目錄
- 行政監察官與正義的追求楊戊龍;彭錦鵬;Gerald E. Caiden・頁 001–020
- 亞太貨幣體系發展下APEC的角色與挑戰李文志(Wen-Chih Lee)・頁 021–060
- 論利維坦的命令:「我們要造人」陳瑞崇(Jui-Chung Chen)・頁 061–096
- 拉克勞(Ernesto Laclau)霸權理論中的敵對與異質性林淑芬(Shu-Fen Lin)・頁 097–130
- 政策倡導聯盟架構之研究:以國道五號蘇花段高速公路為例魯炳炎(Bing-Yan Lu);張永明(Yong-Ming Chang)・頁 131–164