從制度主義解析歐洲聯盟憲法條約草案
EU Constitution-Building: An Institutionalist Analysis
中央研究院歐美研究所(Institute of European and American Studies, Academia Sinica)
摘要
從歐洲聯邦倡議者的角度來看,憲法條約草案不過是個「新瓶裝舊酒」,將行之多年的法規和習慣,集合成一部法典,然後冠上一個新的名詞;但在那些反對歐洲統合者的口中,憲法草約不僅鞏固了聯盟內的超國家結構,還向聯邦建造大幅邁進。與此同時,法律學者則忙於爭辯:憲法草約是否符合憲政主義界定的憲法以及國家憲法必備的功能。本文目的不在參與上述的政治辯論和法律爭議,而企圖引用史考特和拉芬對制度主義的詮釋,從規律、規範和認知「制度三支柱」的角度解析憲法草約主要意涵及其對歐洲統合的影響。作者認為,儘管憲法草約強化了歐盟法律體系、明示歐洲價值並創建各類統合符號,卻斲傷了歐洲聯盟賴以支撐的三個支柱,將促使歐洲統合朝著「不等速」和「政府間互動」的方向發展。作者將這個結果歸咎於九○年代以來歐洲統合理想性的弱化以及歐洲人民對統合運動熱情的迅速消失,並認為要扭轉此一趨勢的惟一途徑是重新論述歐洲統合的理想性並爭取大眾對統合的積極支持。
Abstract
From the federalist view, the Draft Constitutional Treaty may appear as nothing more than "an old bottle for new wine", while Euro-skeptics will condemn it as a further step toward a European super-state. At the same time, jurists and lawyers are busy arguing whether or not this constitutional treaty has met essential criteria defined by constitutionalism. This paper keeps a distance from those political debates and purely legal arguments and focuses its attention on the degree to which this constitutional treaty may contribute to European Integration as a whole. Based upon the three-pillared institutionalism presented by Scott and then developed by Laffan, the author concludes that this constitutional treaty does not advance European Integration as expected by the federalists. Quite to the contrary, though it consolidates the European Union's legal system, creates important symbols for Europe, and presents solemnly European values, the treaty may severely cripple the regulatory, normative and cognitive pillars of the European Union. The author attributes such a crippling effect to the rapid decline of enthusiasm for European Integration in the post-Cold War era. Therefore, the best recipe for reorienting this crippled integration is to rekindle public passion for Europe in a new context totally different from that of fifty, or even twenty, years ago.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 20期
- 出版
- 2004年06月
- 頁碼
- 167–208
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006195
同期目錄
- 德性、干預與個人自由許國賢(Kuo-Hsien Hsu)・頁 001–027
- 對峙的權力觀:行為與結構郭秋永(Chiu-Yeoung Kuo)・頁 029–078
- 找魚:後現代社會科學研究倫理試論石之瑜(Chih-Yu Shih);王宏仁(Hung-Jen Wang);李偉俠(Wei-Hsia Li);李樹山(Shu-Shan Li)・頁 079–102
- 公共服務倫理的理論架構與規範作法施能傑(Jay N. Shih)・頁 103–139
- 非營利管理的責任問題:政治經濟研究途徑孫煒(Way Sun)・頁 141–166
- 從制度主義解析歐洲聯盟憲法條約草案蘇宏達(Hung-Dah Su)・頁 167–208