Rationalism v. Constructivism: Another Great Debate for Coming in International Relations?
理性主義與建構主義的辯論:國際關係理論的另一次大辯論?
政戰學校政治研究所(Institute of Political Science Fu Hsin Kang College)
Abstract (Chinese)
國際關係理論研究正在進行第四次的理論大辯論,建構主義與理性主義是此次辯論的主角,雙方辯論的焦點在於物質因素與理念因素的爭議、關於國際制度的爭論、關於認同與國際規範的爭論、後果性邏輯與適當性邏輯的爭論,以及因果解釋與構成解釋(理解)的爭論。同時,此次大辯論可能發展趨勢會是重組國際關係研究學科本身,而以經驗研究為主,雙方理論的相容與折衷混合。
Abstract
Rationalism vs. constructivism is an ongoing great debate in the International Relations Theory (IRT), the debate topics are on: 1) materials matter or ideas matter in shaping agency's behaviors. 2) international institution's effects. 3) identity formation and international norms compliance. 4) logic of consequences or appropriateness mode of decision-making. 5) explanation or understanding in international studies. This great debate will bring about to reorganize the IRT itself, an empirical research's dominance in IRT, neo-perspectives which integrate the rationalism and constructivism, and the convergence of constructivism and postmodernism.
Keywords
- Journal
- Political Science Review
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- Issue
- No. 19
- Published
- 2003-12
- Pages
- 113–138
- Record ID
- NTUEJ00006200
In this issue
- Breath (Vital Energy), Body and Politics-Analysis on 《Commentary of Lao Tsu》(by Her Shang Gong)林俊宏(Chun-Hung Lin)・pp. 001–034
- The Easy Governing of the Sage Ruler-On the Political Thoughts of Shen Tao許雅棠(Ya-Tang Hsu)・pp. 035–056
- Totalitarianism and Modern Democracy蔡英文(Ying-Wen Tsai)・pp. 057–084
- Democratization and the Effectiveness of Local Action-From the Perspective of a Two-wave Study on the Perceptions of Local Taiwanese Leaders (1993-2001)廖達琪(Da-Chi Liao);黃志呈(Chi-Cheng Huang)・pp. 085–112
- Rationalism v. Constructivism: Another Great Debate for Coming in International Relations?莫大華(Ta-Hua Mo)・pp. 113–138
- Chang Kia-ngau and the Sino-Soviet Negotiations about the Nationalist Government's Restoration of Manchuria during the Early Postwar Period, October 1945-April 1946栗國成(Kuo-Cheng Lee)・pp. 139–180
- NGO and Its Impact on Chinese Human Rights: On the Networking Effect of NGO辛翠玲(Chuei-Ling Shin)・pp. 181–202
- Institutions and Spectrum Allocation: The Empirical Study of Property Right & Policy Credibility周韻采(Yun-Tsai Chou)・pp. 203–224
- Study on Liberalization, Privatization and Security of Universal Service for Postal Service: Experiences of Western Europe and Status of Japan林淑馨(Shu-Hsin Lin)・pp. 225–253
- Taiwan's Industrial Ports Transformation Policy-An Application of Policy Networks and Policy Change Theory魯炳炎(Bing-Yan Lu)・pp. 255–296