張嘉璈與戰後初期中蘇關於「國民政府接收東北」之談判(1945/10~1946/4)
Chang Kia-ngau and the Sino-Soviet Negotiations about the Nationalist Government's Restoration of Manchuria during the Early Postwar Period, October 1945-April 1946
國立臺灣大學國家發展研究所(Graduate Institute of National Development, National Taiwan University)
摘要
二次大戰末期,蘇聯匆促對日宣戰,蘇軍隨即依〈雅爾達協定〉,兵分三路,佔據中國全東北(1945/8~1946/4)。扶植中共勢力進入東北(偶有壓抑),阻撓國民政府軍隊迅速進入該地區;藉以逼使國民政府「親蘇疏美」,及應允合辦東北工礦業,為蘇聯此時主要對華策略。蘇軍撤出東北,則採取能拖則拖戰術。國民政府參與主持接收東北對蘇談判者,在中央為行政院長宋子文,及外交部長王世杰;在長春則為東北行營之熊式輝、張嘉璈、蔣經國。張嘉璈根據其自身與蘇方接觸經驗,力主國民政府不妨曲從蘇聯不當之要求,儘速與之議定「中蘇東北經濟合作協定」,則蘇聯或能儘速撤軍,並讓國軍迅速進入東北(至少可據有南滿);以免夜長夢多,使中共得志於東北,而將不利於國民政府之大局。蔣經國大體同意張氏主張。在中央之宋子文、王世杰,或者由於親身參與《中蘇友好同盟條約》談判之不良印象,極端反對張氏見解,力主除非蘇軍完全自東北撤出,將不與之議定東北經濟合作協定。蔣中正傾向於宋、王見解。此一決策之制定,或即為其後國民政府失利於東北的原因之一。就維護國家民族之尊嚴及利益角度觀察,宋、王主張,應為無誤;惟就現實政治之利害關係言,宋、王主張或不免失之理想,只能迫使蘇聯更加支持中共,反不若張氏主張之務實。於此是否也突顯了在那段艱辛的談判歲月中(1945/10∼1946/4),張嘉璈氏也算得上是一位別具「卓識」的政府談判代表。
Abstract
Chang Kia-ngau was a Chinese banker and a high rank offical in the Nationalist Government before the end of World War II. During the latter part of the Sino-Japanese War (1943 to 1945), he had lived in US and served as a government sponsored researcher focusing on the problems of economies and reconstructions of China during the postwar period. In September 1945, he was assigned as the Chairman of the Economic Commission of the Northeast Headquarters of the Nationalist Government, which was one of the positions to negotiate with the Commander of the Soviet Red Army in Manchuria about the restoration of it from Russia to China. Supporting the Army of the Chinese Communist Party to gain controls of parts of Manchuria and expelling the US influence from it were the main strategic targets of the USSR during the early postwar period. Meanwhile, obstructing the entrance of the Nationalist Army into Manchuria deliberately and hoping to sign an agreement with Her about the Sino-Soviet Economic Cooperation in Manchuria were two other important strategic targets of the USSR. Facing the above complex and subtle external situation, T.V. Soong and Wang Shih-chieh, the prime minister and the minister of the Foreign Affairs of the Nationalist Government respectively, set the policies for issues related to Manchuria that China wouldn't negotiate with any economic cooperation in Manchuria with Russia unless the Red Army evacuated completely. These policies consequently led to the failure of the Nationalist Government to regain Manchuria from the Red Army in the spring of 1946. During that period, Chang Kia-ngau was one of few important officials in the Nationalist Government claiming that China should be admitted to have an agreement of the economic cooperation in Manchuria with Russia due to the possibility that the Red Army might subsequently assist the Nationalist Army to advance towards Manchuria smoothly. Therefore, the Nationalist Army could at least have the possibility to occupy southern parts of Manchuria. Although Mr. Chang's opinions were suppressed by his directors, his flexible and pragmatistic stands and the excellent foresight should have been consented.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 政治科學論叢
- ISSN
- 1018-3892
- 卷期
- 19期
- 出版
- 2003年12月
- 頁碼
- 139–180
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006201
同期目錄
- 氣、身體舆政治-《老子河上公注》的政治思想分析林俊宏(Chun-Hung Lin)・頁 001–034
- 聖人無事-愼到政治思想試說許雅棠(Ya-Tang Hsu)・頁 035–056
- 極權主義與現代民主蔡英文(Ying-Wen Tsai)・頁 057–084
- 民主化與地方的行動效能-從台灣兩波(1993~2001)地方菁英的認知判斷探析廖達琪(Da-Chi Liao);黃志呈(Chi-Cheng Huang)・頁 085–112
- 理性主義與建構主義的辯論:國際關係理論的另一次大辯論?莫大華(Ta-Hua Mo)・頁 113–138
- 張嘉璈與戰後初期中蘇關於「國民政府接收東北」之談判(1945/10~1946/4)栗國成(Kuo-Cheng Lee)・頁 139–180
- 從中國人權問題看國際人權團體的影響力-論非政府組織及其連結作用辛翠玲(Chuei-Ling Shin)・頁 181–202
- 頻譜核釋與制度:財產權與公信力的實證研究周韻采(Yun-Tsai Chou)・頁 203–224
- 郵政事業自由化、民營化與普及服務確保之研究:西歐國家經驗和日本現況林淑馨(Shu-Hsin Lin)・頁 225–253
- 我國工業專用港轉型改制為工商綜合港之公共政策觀點-政策網絡與政策變遷的應用魯炳炎(Bing-Yan Lu)・頁 255–296