A Critical Appraisal of Initiatives of Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) for the Blue Economy: Deadlocks and Any Possible Way Out?
School of Law, University of Birmingham
摘要
The article will critically evaluate Asia-Pacific Economic
Cooperation’s (hereinafter “APEC”) Blue Economy
implementations as well as ocean governance of the Comprehensive
and Progressive Trans-Pacific Partnership (hereinafter “CPTPP”)
Agreement. APEC’s Xiamen Declaration on the Blue Economy
pledges to advance sustainable ocean and coastal governance for
purposes of fostering economic growth, including scaling up marine
protected areas, tackling illegal fishing and facilitating sustainable
regional trade in fish. However, the effectiveness of APEC’s
initiatives for the Blue Economy and its implementation are doubtful
due to its talk-shop nature.
APEC has performed a reform of disciplining fisheries subsidies
which have been a principal factor leading to depleted fishery
stocks. By contrast, APEC has been criticized with regard to its
inability to complete sensitive or complex goals, such as achieving
sustainable development of the Blue Economy. This inability might
arise from APEC’s de facto institutional character, which shows a
lack of an establishing treaty conferring on APEC an international legal personality. Nevertheless, APEC can develop a binding
agreement following the example of the Information Technology
Agreement (ITA) which was initiated by APEC and adopted at the
WTO’s 1996 Singapore Ministerial Conference with support from
APEC member economies. A recent mega-regional trade agreement
in the Asia-Pacific region—CPTPP—would be another possible
option for advancing the Blue Economy in the Asia-Pacific region.
It is widely recognized that CPTPP has a series of novel and
enforceable regulations concerning fishery sustainability. One of the
CPTPP’s priorities is to combat illegal, unreported and unregulated
(IUU) fishing by placing a restriction on trade. In addition, CPTPP’s
environmental chapter contains a binding dispute settlement
mechanism. The final section is to refer to the European Union
(hereinafter “EU”) model. The EU is a supranational and regional
body with enforceable power. EU fishery regulations could be a
model for the Asia-Pacific region in the sense of the substance of its
rules. The EU has a more complex rule of regulating fishing and
fisheries subsidies, such as the Regulation No. 508/2014 directing
EU member states to use European Maritime and Fisheries Fund.
This article concludes that the CPTPP turns out to be a better policy
choice for advancing the Blue Economy, in comparison with the
APEC. With regard to improving CPTPP’s ocean governance, this
article suggests to refer to the EU fishery regulations.
Abstract
The article will critically evaluate Asia-Pacific Economic
Cooperation’s (hereinafter “APEC”) Blue Economy
implementations as well as ocean governance of the Comprehensive
and Progressive Trans-Pacific Partnership (hereinafter “CPTPP”)
Agreement. APEC’s Xiamen Declaration on the Blue Economy
pledges to advance sustainable ocean and coastal governance for
purposes of fostering economic growth, including scaling up marine
protected areas, tackling illegal fishing and facilitating sustainable
regional trade in fish. However, the effectiveness of APEC’s
initiatives for the Blue Economy and its implementation are doubtful
due to its talk-shop nature.
APEC has performed a reform of disciplining fisheries subsidies
which have been a principal factor leading to depleted fishery
stocks. By contrast, APEC has been criticized with regard to its
inability to complete sensitive or complex goals, such as achieving
sustainable development of the Blue Economy. This inability might
arise from APEC’s de facto institutional character, which shows a
lack of an establishing treaty conferring on APEC an international legal personality. Nevertheless, APEC can develop a binding
agreement following the example of the Information Technology
Agreement (ITA) which was initiated by APEC and adopted at the
WTO’s 1996 Singapore Ministerial Conference with support from
APEC member economies. A recent mega-regional trade agreement
in the Asia-Pacific region—CPTPP—would be another possible
option for advancing the Blue Economy in the Asia-Pacific region.
It is widely recognized that CPTPP has a series of novel and
enforceable regulations concerning fishery sustainability. One of the
CPTPP’s priorities is to combat illegal, unreported and unregulated
(IUU) fishing by placing a restriction on trade. In addition, CPTPP’s
environmental chapter contains a binding dispute settlement
mechanism. The final section is to refer to the European Union
(hereinafter “EU”) model. The EU is a supranational and regional
body with enforceable power. EU fishery regulations could be a
model for the Asia-Pacific region in the sense of the substance of its
rules. The EU has a more complex rule of regulating fishing and
fisheries subsidies, such as the Regulation No. 508/2014 directing
EU member states to use European Maritime and Fisheries Fund.
This article concludes that the CPTPP turns out to be a better policy
choice for advancing the Blue Economy, in comparison with the
APEC. With regard to improving CPTPP’s ocean governance, this
article suggests to refer to the EU fishery regulations.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 17卷1期
- 出版
- 2022年03月
- 頁碼
- 85–113
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000063
同期目錄
- Foreword to the Special Issue on “Building a Sustainable Future: New Asian Regionalism in International Economic Law”Pasha L. Hsieh・頁 1–5
- Quantizing Geoeconomics: Emerging Geoeconomics in International Economic Law Through a Quantum WorldviewXinyue Li・頁 5–39
- Current Development of Fisheries Subsidies Regulations After the Failure of WTO Doha Round Negotiations with a Focus on the Asia-Pacific RegionChen-Ju Chen・頁 41–84
- A Critical Appraisal of Initiatives of Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) for the Blue Economy: Deadlocks and Any Possible Way Out?I-Ju Chen・頁 85–113
- Mapping Sustainable Development in Investment Treaties: An Analysis of ASEAN States’ PracticeMark McLaughlin・頁 115–140
- The Inclusion of Anti-Corruption Clauses in International Investment Agreements and Its Possible Systemic ImplicationsYueming Yan・頁 141–173
- Access to Essential Medicines and International Health Law: Towards a New Paradigm?Rabaï Bouderhem・頁 175–200
- Public Health Policy Space for Responding to Potential Pandemics Under the SCM AgreementYing-Jun Lin & Feng-Jen Tsai・頁 201–238
- Shedding Any New Light? The WTO’s Latest Ruling in the US-China Solar BattleMeng (Mandy) Fang・頁 239–277
- A Book Review on Pasha L. Hsieh, “New Asian Regionalism in International Economic Law” (Cambridge University Press, 2021)Yuka Fukunaga・頁 279–286