代表型式:持續與轉變
Representational Forms: Continuity and Change
國立政治大學(National Chengchi University )
- 卷期
- 8期
- 出版
- 1997年06月
- 頁碼
- 133–145
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006312
摘要
本文旨在探討「比較政治」學門上,有關代表型式「新」、「舊」之爭辯及持續性之問題。首先,作者分析並比較隸屬「舊政治典範」下,由多元主義、統合主義與馬克斯主義主導之代表型式。大致而言,此一典範下代表型式之主要標的係「客觀存在之利益」。透過制度性管道,諸如政黨或利益團體,社會不同利益得以上陳國家機構(多元主義),國家亦可導引此等利益之形成(統合主義),原本在資本主義「被扭曲」之無產階級利益可獲平等反映(馬克斯主義)。其次,作者臚列「新政治典範」下代表型式(即「新社會運動」之主要特徵。概言之,此一代表型式係以「認同」為訴求主軸,並追求不同團體在國家及民間社會之普遍及公平參與機會。再次,作者論述「新」與「舊」典範下之不同代表型式之持續性與差異性。其中,就前者而言,無論「新」或「舊」型式,行為者均在特定時空之政策制定或政治界定過程中,爭取被接納之參與;就後者而言,相對於「舊」典範之肯定「現代性」之價值,「新社會運動」往往著重「後現代性」之訴求。(例如揭櫫「反官僚化」、「人性化」、「自主性」之價值。)最後,作者建議:學界或可藉由理論之重組,將不同對比之類型置於一新建構「連續光譜」之兩端,並釐清各類型之定義及面向,藉以調和原各該典範之分歧,澄清持續性與轉變性之問題。
Abstract
This essay mainly deals with the question of the extent to which the mode of representation has changed, as revolving around "old politics" vs
"new" debates in contemporary Comparative Politics literature. First, this author analyzes the representation forms highlighted in pluralism,
corporatism and Marxism, as subsumed under "old paradigm". Briefly, the main "object" to be represented is "objectively existent interest". Through some institutional channels, such as political parties or interest groups, varied interests can be transmitted from society into the state (pluralism), or intermediated via the state (corporatism). And the socialist party-states can reflect the genuine interests of the proletariat that once were distorted in Capitalist societies. (Marxism) Further, the author highlights some key features of new representations (or "new social movements"). In short, they center on "identity" and pursue mostly community-based rights for universal and equal representations in both the state and civil society. Then, the author compares the "old" and "new" forms in terms of similarities and differences. For example, agents in both forms similarly strive to be included in the process of defining the meanings of politics or in the policy process across time and space. As to the differences, while the "old" appreciates the merit of "modernity", the "new" tends to be more "post-modernist"-oriented in appealing to such causes of "anti-bureaucratization" and "autonomy". Finally, this author suggests that the "change vs continuity" debate probably could be reconciled, if not resolved, by bringing the two apparently "incompatible" models as endpoints of a newly constructed continuum in which dimensions of each model can be further clarified.