臺大學術期刊資料庫NTU Journal Database

比較杜魯門與布希總統危機處理政策─以韓戰及波斯灣戰爭為例

A Comparative Study of Crisis Management Policy in the Truman and Bush Administrations: The Korean War and Persian Gulf War as Case Studies

林正義(Cheng-Yi Lin)

中央研究院歐美研究所(Institute of European and American Studies, Academia Sinica)

卷期
5期
出版
1994年04月
頁碼
137–159
編號
NTUEJ00006352
外部連結本篇全文由原出版單位的網站提供。

連結出處:國立臺灣大學政治學系網頁。連結會開啟本資料庫以外的網站,能否閱讀由該網站決定。

摘要

就決策者而言,危機決策與計劃政策決策的不同點有三。危機決策的特質為驚訝無預警;有戰爭的可能性;反應時間有限。在外交政策危機期間,美國總統透過白宮、國會、重要外國領袖的三方面互動,達成決策。總統通常重視國家安全會議其他法定成員(如副總統、國務卿、國防部長)的意見,並密切觀察國會議員的反應。美國盟邦的態度,尤其是聯合國安理會常任理事國的立場,亦會影響總統的危機處理政策。由韓戰與波斯灣戰爭的個案顯示,美國總統在決策過程的角色最關鍵,而杜魯門與布希總統均利用聯合國來合理化美國在海外的軍事干預。杜魯門總統傾向召開國家安全會議以達成決策,布希總統則較喜非正式與兩三位重要顧問磋商。杜魯門總統監督甚至有時介入軍事行動的進行,而布希總統對戰場指揮官則有較大的授權。韓戰爆發之後,美國國會議員對杜魯門總統處理韓戰政策加以支持,並無充份廣泛辯論。在波斯灣危機期間,布希經常知會國會議員,但國會對於使用所有必要手段驅逐伊拉克離開科威特,卻陷入分裂的狀態。韓戰及波斯灣戰爭是集體安全運作的兩個例子。布希總統較幸運處於冷戰時代,他的危機決策少受蘇聯及中共的阻擾。然而,集體安全制度的重要性提升,將使美國在未來外交政策危機處理時,議價籌碼相對減少。

Abstract

For decision-makers, crisis decisions are different from program policy decisions because the former have three characteristics: surprise, a possibility of war, and limited time to respond. During a foreign policy crisis, the US President usually reaches his decisions through interactions among the White House, Congress, and some key foreign leaders. The President usually values highly opinions of other National Security Council members and watches closely what actions Congress takes. The attitudes of US allies and, particularly permanent members of the UN Security Council, will also influence the President’s crisis management policy. Through case studies of the Korean War and Persian Gulf War, one can conclude that the President is the crucial person in decision-making process and both Truman and Bush utilized the UN Security Council resolutions as justifications for US overseas military intervention. President Truman tended to convene the National Security Council meetings to reach his decision, while Bush preferred to consult informally with a couple of key advisors, President Truman monitored and sometimes intervened in the process of military operations, while Bush had more trust in the theater commander in carrying out the war plans. Members of Congress had little debate and were united behind Truman’s management of the Korean Crisis. President Bush endeavored to keep members of Congress informed during the Persian Gulf crisis, but Congress was divided in the wisdom of using all necessary means to expel Iraq from Kuwait. The Korean War and Persian Gulf War are examples of the functioning of a collective security system. President Bush was luckier to live in the Post-Cold War era and his decisions were hardly obstructed by the Soviet Union and the People’s Republic of China. The rising importance of a collective security system, however, means that the US has less leverage in future foreign policy crisis management.

程式與 AI 助手可以改用資料介面(JSON、MCP),查詢比讀頁面快。給程式與 AI 代理的存取說明