臺大學術期刊資料庫NTU Journal Database

柏克對美國革命與法國革命的不同態度

Burke on the Revolutions in America and France

陳思賢(Sy-Shyan Chen)

國立臺灣大學政治學系(Department of Political Science, National Taiwan University)

卷期
4期
出版
1992年12月
頁碼
081–105
編號
NTUEJ00006362
外部連結本篇全文由原出版單位的網站提供。

連結出處:國立臺灣大學政治學系網頁。連結會開啟本資料庫以外的網站,能否閱讀由該網站決定。

摘要

柏克是英國十八世紀思想史中備受爭議人物,不只因為他對當時所發生的兩次革命持完全不同之態度,也因為他在輝格思想傳統中抱持著極特殊的立場。在對美國事務的處理上,他曾數度發表立場極為自由派的主張和解與寬容之文章,而令托利黨人及朝廷不滿;但對法國革命他卻痛加撻伐,絲毫不假借,以致連他的托利黨友都無法諒解,而甚至保皇派及朝廷在一開始時亦不知何以待之。卻對柏克進行了解,我們將以十八世紀之歷史為經緯,才可能深入探究他的傳統主義及古憲法思想的意識型態淵源,並對他獨特的政治經濟學觀點找到解釋的基點。柏克實在可謂是生存在近代英國發展史上的關鍵時段,而他的思想也含攝了對當時所有重要的議題的看法,或是對這些看法的批評,故就英國政治思想而言,柏克實應可視為一個關鍵的時期中的一個關鍵人物。

Abstract

Edmund Burks is a controversial figure, in lieu not only of this different attitudes towards the eighteenth-century revolutions, but of his peculiar appearance as a new and old Whig at the same time. He drafted the Rockingham Whigs North American policy speeches delivered in the Parliament during the 1760’s and the 1770’s, which reflected a liberal democratic stance not readily acceptable to either the Tory politicians or His Majesty George Ⅲ. Yet it was the same person to have appealed to conservatism and traditionalism, in the 1790’s, to the extent that his Whig colleagues felt betrayed and his Tory foes puzzled outright. To help reach a more accurate portrayal of Burke, history and thought of the early modern England is examined in so far as Burke’s political economy and ancient constitutionalism are inviting our investigations. If we take Hanoverian England as a pivotal point in time for an industrial-commercial society to take shape, Burke may then be the figure from whose thought the major ideological underpinnings of this particular period could be erected. And it is suggested in the final part that an eighteenth century thinker such as Burke would see the subsequent eras as totally unfamiliar, in spite of the role which his own had played in the process of European modernization.

程式與 AI 助手可以改用資料介面(JSON、MCP),查詢比讀頁面快。給程式與 AI 代理的存取說明