政治精英與法治不彰之關係─台灣基層民選政治精英之分析
The Relationships between Political Elties and Failure of Rule-by-Law -- An Analysis on Local Elected Elites in Taiwan
國立臺灣大學政治學系(Department of Political Science, National Taiwan University)
- 卷期
- 4期
- 出版
- 1992年12月
- 頁碼
- 131–148
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006364
摘要
一般社會精英對社會價值與社會行為具有領導與示範的效果,因此,政治精英對人民的民主價值與法治行為自然亦深具引導與示範的地位。為此,檢驗一個國家政治精英的民主法治認知及其特權違法行為之關係,以及檢討影響這些政治精英或人物的特權違法行為的背景與因素,應有助於促進一個國家法治社會的早日建立。本文主要研究對象為臺灣鄉鎮(市)級民選政治精英(鄉鎮市民代表及鄉鎮市長)。旨在探討基層選政治人物的民主法治認知結構及其特權違法行為。
這些基層民選政治精英的特權違法行為包括人事關說、工程關說、違警關說、違規行業與行為的保護,及其他如銀行貸款、公家機關採購的分贓、都市發展計劃的變更等特許、特惠利益的壟斷與保護。這些行為均嚴重影響行政中立,弱化政府威信,破壞法律公正,損害法律尊嚴,鼓勵法律投機,阻礙法治的建立。這些研究,除了利於了解民選政治精英特權違法行為對法治社會建立的危害與影響之外,亦將有助於了解民主法治在基層推動的困難。
Abstract
Social elites always play the leading and influential role on social value and people’s behavior. Political elites, eventually, play a guilding and examplary actor profoundly on peoples’ democratic value and legal behavior as well. Therefore, an examination on the relationships between political elites’ democratic-legal cognition and their privilege action, also, examining the impact factors on the illegal privilege action to those politicians, are both very useful to push a country to be ruled by law. This paper intends to analyze the relationships between the cognition structure of rule-by-law and the illegal privilege action on the elected grass-root politicians in Taiwan. These illegal privilege acts which had been done by some local elected politicians, include the extortion and solicitation on personnel, construction cases, purchases and the monopoly or protection of special reciprocal benefits. These acts are seriously damage the neutrality of administration, weakening the prestige of government, harming the law justice, hurting to the dignity of law and encouraging the risks which against the law. These phenomena should block the way for the construction of a rule-by-law society. I believe that such a study will do some contribution to understand that how elected politicians’ privilege behaviors influence the construction of a rule-by-law society. Certainly, it will also be helpful to understand the difficulties to the realization of a rule-by-law local society in the developing countries.