臺大學術期刊資料庫NTU Journal Database

我國近代民主政治的個案研究:廣西省的學步民主●1907-1937●

The Immature Democracy in Modern China, Kwangsi as a Case

朱浤源(Hong-Yuan CHU)

中央研究院近代史研究所(Institute of Modern History, Academia Sinica)

卷期
1期
出版
1990年03月
頁碼
089–124
編號
NTUEJ00006389
外部連結本篇全文由原出版單位的網站提供。

連結出處:國立臺灣大學政治學系網頁。連結會開啟本資料庫以外的網站,能否閱讀由該網站決定。

摘要

文化的演進是緩慢的,要變化某個社會的氣質,所需的時間往往在百年以上。我國從清末開始,原打算以九年的時間預備立憲,當時被國人批評太慢,以為清廷是在拖延,沒有誠意。其實不然。清末行民主,不但誠懇,而且力行,祇是太急了些。反而是民國建立之後,民主的步調亂了。等蔣中正北伐以後,才依照孫中山的建國三程序,於軍政之後行訓政。惟訓政於若干年內即告結束,俾迅速進入憲政體制。從歷史的長遠角度看來,仍嫌過於急躁。本文藉著廣西的個案,使讀者一方面了解西省於清末以及民國二十年以後,確有誠意實行議會民主制,另一方面更清楚看到一個民主根荄未具的地區,想在三十年內從傳統帝王君主制改變為議會民主制是根本不可能的事情,因為民主的形式的深處,尚有民主的實質更加重要。而要達成實質的民主,除了法制要健全、行政機構要有為、司法要公允、治安要穩定之外,又須在政治之外的經濟、教育、財政等方面,具備相當的條件。從這個了解來看當年的廣西,就更容易明白其學步民主難有所成的根本原因。

Abstract

The Ching Court, at the end of its rule, planned to set up local, autonomy system within a very short span of 9 years. It pushed the local governments so hard in order to complete the project of constitutional monarchy. It was unlikely to be successful as civic culture could not be formed within such a short time. But we discover that the regime did try its best. The dynasty itself, however, had been overturned before it completed the project. The progress for democracy slowed down in the early republican era, unfortunately, owing to the continuous political instabilities. The effort was reinforced only after the Northern Expedition. From 1928 Chiang Kai-shek followed Sun Yat-sen’s design via entering China a period of tutelage strengthening the temporary necessity of one-party autocracy in order to discipline people the way for democracy. He was not successful, either, due to both domestic and international pressures. Kwangsi province in this article serves as a mirror of the immature democracy at the beginning of this century. From which the slow nature of the development of political culture can be witnessed.

程式與 AI 助手可以改用資料介面(JSON、MCP),查詢比讀頁面快。給程式與 AI 代理的存取說明