The Impact of a Raise in Reimbursement: A Payment Increase for Vaginal Delivery in 2005 as an Example
調高健保給付對醫療品質之影響: 以2005年自然產給付調高為例
政治大學財政學系 (Department of Public Finance, National ChengChi University);淡江大學會計學系 (Department of Accounting, Tamkang University)
Abstract (Chinese)
2005年5月健保局將自然產給付加倍, 調整至與剖腹產給付一致,期望透過自然產給付增加, 來降低剖腹產率並改善醫療品質。這自然產給付增加提供了一個檢視給付提高對醫療品質改善機會。本文使用2004與2006年生產案件, 以健保給付當作醫師所得的替代變數,醫療品質則以剖腹產率、 住院天數、 再住院率進行觀察,分析醫師所得增加和醫療品質間因果關係。為控制醫療時無法觀察因子, 估計時選用初產產婦,並採用 「一階差分」 方式來排除內生性偏誤。結果顯示給付增加對剖腹產率沒有顯著關係,但原先自然產比例較高醫師剖腹產率卻有降低;另外, 自然產再住院率也顯著下降。我們進一步針對幾個解釋剖腹產偏低效果進行檢驗,發現產婦個人偏好剖腹產是一個可能原因。最後, 我們發現這給付調整效果並未外溢到同醫院的婦科、兒科治療。
Abstract
In May 2005, Bureau of National Health Insurance doubled the reimbursement for vaginal delivery to the same rate as paid for cesarean section (c-section) in order to reduce the c-section rate and improve the quality of care. This reimbursement adjustment provides an excellent opportunity to examine whether such a payment increase can improve healthcare quality. Using obstetric cases of firstborns in 2004 and 2006 from National Health Insurance Data, this study examines if there was a negative relation between quality indicators (e.g. c-section, re-admission, and length of stay) and doctor's income, measured in terms of payments paid by NHI for baby delivery. To control for the endogenous bias, the study employs ``first-difference'' methods to attenuate the bias arising from unobserved factors, and restricts the sample to firstborn babies. Our results indicate that the doctor's income and c-section rate is statistically uncorrelated on the whole, but negatively related for doctors who previously had a lower percentage of c-sections. Additionally, we found the payment reduces both the 14 and 30 days re-admission after vaginal delivery. Furthermore, the analysis indicates that one explanation --- a c-section is preferred by women for the sake of personal reasons --- is largely consistent with our empirical findings. Finally, we found the effect of the payment increase did not spill over to gynecology or pediatric services in the same hospital.
Keywords
- Section
- Articles
- Journal
- Taiwan Economic Review
- ISSN
- 1018-3833
- Issue
- Vol. 47, No. 4
- Published
- 2019-12
- Pages
- 621–664
- Record ID
- NTUEJ00006659
In this issue
- Ranking of Economics Journals: the 2019 Update林明仁(Ming-Jen Lin);林常青(Chang-Ching Lin);張俊仁(Juin-Jen Chang);曹添旺(Tien-Wang Tsaur);楊浩彥(Hao-Yen Yang)・pp. 503–542
- Median Location and Economic Geography蔡智發(Jyh-Fa Tsai)・pp. 543–578
- Measuring the Connectedness of Returns and Volatilities in Asian Stock Markets徐士勛(Shih-Hsun Hsu);李佳罄(Jia-Cing Lee)・pp. 579–620
- The Impact of a Raise in Reimbursement: A Payment Increase for Vaginal Delivery in 2005 as an Example連賢明(Hsien-Ming Lien);韓幸紋(Hsing-Wen Han)・pp. 621–664