嘉南大圳的成本收益分析
A Cost-and-Benefit Analysis of Chia-Nan Channels
國立臺灣大學經濟系(Department of Economics, National Taiwan University);國立臺灣大學經濟系(Department of Economics, National Taiwan University);英飛凌(Infineon) 公司(Infineon Technologies);安捷倫(Agilent)公司(Agilent Technologies)
- 卷期
- 34卷3期
- 出版
- 2006年09月
- 頁碼
- 335–372
- 編號
- NTUEJ00006881
摘要
日治時期台灣的農業發展相當可觀,而學者多認為水利建設是重要關鍵之一。日治時期的農田水利建設以嘉南大圳規模最大,它是由總督府與農民合資興建。大圳之規模雖大,但其供水仍不足以滿足嘉南平原農作之所需,因此而實施三年輪灌的給水制度。這強制的給水制度受到當時學者如矢內原忠雄(1929)的詬病,認為是日本糖業資本家宰制台灣農民的一種手段。本文嘗試計算嘉南大圳的成本與收益。根據我們的計算結果,嘉南大圳顯著提升嘉南地區的農民所得,卻對糖廠影響不大。
Abstract
Agriculture in Taiwan developed rapidly in the Japanese colonial era. The irrigation systems constructed then were generally considered a key factor in this success. Chia-Nan Channels, co-financed by the Governor-General and local farmers, was the largest irrigation system constructed. Despite its large scale, the water supply was still insufficient to irrigate the whole Chia-Nan Plain. In response to this, a 3-year crop rotation plan was executed and farmers had to take turns irrigating their land. This water regulation has been considered a means by which Japanese sugar capitalists exploited Taiwanese farmers, and was criticized by scholars at that time, e.g., Yanaihara (1929). This paper makes a cost-and-benefit analysis of Chia-Nan Channels. Our calculation shows that Chia-Nan Channels actually enhanced the farmer's income significantly, and its impact on a sugar mill's profit was only marginal.