傳顧愷之〈女史箴圖〉畫外的幾個問題
Beyond the Admonitions Scroll: A Study of Its Mounting, Seals and Inscriptions
國立故宮博物院書畫處(Department of Painting and Calligraphy National Palace Museum)
摘要
今日所見大英博物館藏顧愷之〈女史箴圖〉,經過歷代輾轉流傳,畫幅上多出收傳印記,裝裱也變度變異。本文不討論繪畫本身,而是希望從著錄及畫上的題跋及印記,對此畫的流傳經過有所了解。畫卷上因有「弘文之印」,而曾被為由唐代皇室收藏,遺憾的是這是顆偽印。而宋徽宗的「睿思東閤」印,與「內府圖書之印」雖為,「圖書之印」位置卻違反慣例,很可能是從其它地方移過來的。其他「宣和」小印及宋高宗的「紹興」諸印,也都是後來才添上的偽印。印章不會隨使用者的亡亡而消朱。「賢志堂印」本為宋高宗吳皇后用印,然而此印到明朝為華夏(約1465-1566)所有。這引起何時鈐蓋的惑,而由於「廣仁殿」印是偽,「群玉中祕」印是真,因此此卷是否曾歸入金內府或章宗(1168-1208)的收藏,也令人困惑。此外,卷後金章宗〈書女史箴文〉,在明代嚴嵩(1480-1565)收藏時,是獨立的一件;直到梁清標(1620-1691)時,才將兩件裝成一件。這也可以從〈書女史箴文〉上,有裁切的痕跡看出來。〈女史箴圖〉前黃裱綾存有騎縫半字題記:「卷字柒拾號」,則可能為明代查抄事件的紀錄字號。
Abstract
The Admonitions of the Instructress to the Count Ladies scroll has passed through the hands of many collectors over the centuries, and its has been stamped by many seals and remounted for many times. The concern in this paper is not with the painting itself, but with the collecting activities rebuilt from records, inscriptions and seals about or on the scroll. Because there is a ‘Hong wen zhi yin’ on the scroll, it has been induced that the painting was once in the Tang imperial collection. But, in fact, this seal is fake. Although the ‘Ruisi Dongge’ and the ‘Neifu tushu zhi yin’ of Huizong are genuine, the placements of the ‘Neifu tushuy zhi yin’ is not as usual. It’s highly possible that the two seals were removed from other works. The small ‘Xuanhe’ seals and the ‘Shaoxing’ seals of Gaozong are all fake that added later. Seals will not disappear when their owners die. The original owner of the seal ‘Xianzhitang yin’ was Gaozong’s wife, but it became to be in the possession of Hua Hsia (ca. 1465-1566) in Ming dynasty. These facts confuse us on which one impressed the seal on the painting. We also confused about if it was once in the imperial collection of Jin dynasty or Zhangzong (1168-1208). Because although the seal ‘Guangrendian’ is fake, the seal ‘Oun yu zhong mi’ is acceptable. Moreover, the transcription of the ‘Admonitions’ written by Zhangzong follows the painting was not part of the scroll when Yan Song (1480-1565) owned it. The painting and the transcription were not mounted together until they are in Liang Qing-biao’s (1620-1691) hand. We can see that by observing the cutting edges of the transcription. In the top left corner of the front border-panel of the Admonitions is inscribed half of an accession or inventory number, which reads ‘Juan zi qishi hao’, it might be the confiscatory record by Ming government.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 美術史研究集刊
- ISSN
- 1023-2095
- 卷期
- 17期
- 出版
- 2004年09月
- 頁碼
- 001–051
- 編號
- NTUEJ00007254
同期目錄
- 傳顧愷之〈女史箴圖〉畫外的幾個問題王耀庭(Yao-ting Wang)・頁 001–051
- 「畫史」集註(6):第一六一條至第一百七十條古原宏伸(Kohara Hironobu)・頁 053–159
- 十五至十六世紀日本的中國陶瓷鑑賞與收藏謝明良(Hsieh Ming-liang)・頁 161–190
- 莎莉‧曼恩兒童攝影中的母性拜物主義劉瑞琪(Jui-Ch'i Liu)・頁 191–226