從文字到圖像─探討大英本《女史箴》畫卷的圖文關係
From Text to Images: A Case Study of the Admonitions Scroll in the British Museum
國立臺灣大學藝術史研究所(Graduate Institute of Art History National Taiwan University)
摘要
本文主要探討傳顧愷之(約344-405)《女史箴圖》(大英博物館藏)的圖像語文本之間的關係。主要的議題包括:1.畫家如何將張華(232-300)所做〈女史箴〉原文轉譯成圖像;.他如何利用圖像表現〈女史箴〉文中的儒家倫理概念。畫家將全文分為十二段,每段文字之左各配一段圖畫,行成一連串單景式構圖。畫家採用直譯,隱喻,象徵,反諷,和諧音等技法將每段文字內涵轉譯成圖像;他以七段畫面宣揚自我犧牲、壓抑情感、謙和忍讓、和繁衍子孫等儒家婦德,而以三段畫面貶抑表面修儀、夫婦相疑、以治容求好等行為;此外,他更利用人物大小比例及表情動作的差異,強調男尊女卑和上下階層的區別。總之,畫家運用淵博的之事及豐富的想像力,以圖畫巧妙地轉譯了〈女史箴〉一文的故事內容和微言大意。
Abstract
Attributed to Ku K'ai-chih 顧愷之(c. A.D. 344-405), The Admonitions of the instructress to Court Ladies (Nu-shih chen 女史箴) in the British Museum illustrates the text of the same title written by Chang Hua 張華 (A.D. 232-300) in the voice of an instructress to advise Emperor Chia 賈后 (d. A.D. 300) of her role as a virtuous court lady. This paper focuses on two issues regarding the text/image relationships of the scroll: First how did the artist create the images for the corresponding text? Second, how does this painting represent the didactic meaning of the text? With three scenes missing from the beginning, the British Museum's Admonitions consists of nine scenes proceeding from right to left, each illustration following a passage of text in a sequence of monoscenic compositions. In order to convert the “Admonitions” text into an interesting painting, the artist experimented with many translation strategies, including literal, metaphorical, and suggestive. He also exercised great imagination to convey Confucian values advocated in the text through his choices of subjects and representation of figures: throughout the entire scroll, the meritorious deeds and the virtues of women, such as self-sacrifice, emotional suppression, prudence, sincerity, and obedience, are emphasized and shown in seven scenes; while unacceptable behaviors and attitudes, including narcissism, speaking with evil intent, and seeking the love of a man, are denounced and represented sparingly in three scenes. Also, the hierarchy of Confucian ethics is revealed in the treatment of figural forms: the ruler and the ruled as well as the dominator and the dominated are clearly differentiated in their varied dresses, facial expressions, and body language.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 美術史研究集刊
- ISSN
- 1023-2095
- 卷期
- 12期
- 出版
- 2002年03月
- 頁碼
- 035–061
- 編號
- NTUEJ00007275
同期目錄
- 傳顧愷之「女史箴圖」與中國藝術史方聞(Wen C. Fong)・頁 001–033
- 從文字到圖像─探討大英本《女史箴》畫卷的圖文關係陳葆真(Chen Pao-chen)・頁 035–061
- 畫史集註(一)序詞—第三十條古原宏伸(Kohara Hironobu)・頁 063–168
- 遼與北宋舍利塔內藏經之研究沈雪曼(Shen Hsueh-men)・頁 169–212
- 漢斯‧哈克的文化政治探索曾少千(Tseng Shao-chien)・頁 213–284