六朝形神生滅論爭中的玄思綜論
A Comprehensive Investigation on Metaphysical Thoughts in the Views about Body and Spirit in the Six Dynasties
國立中山大學中國文學系副教授(Associate Professor, Department of Chinese Literature, National Sun Yat-sen University.)
摘要
本文嘗試以「玄論」的視角,思考玄學與清談文化對六朝形神生滅問題所發揮的影響,進而尋繹個中思維相承的脈絡意義,以此增益對相關問題的理解層次。從背景研究的角度來看,「形神生滅」議題,在佛教未盛之前,較早的發端,可以溯源自「無鬼論」、「夢論」等,因個中所反映的形神理解,多成為後世「形神生滅論」談論之所資。而玄學中的「本末有無論」、「自然觀」、「體∕用」觀念等,則又成為最常被應用的論述思維模式。職是,適如清談在南朝的發展,有著多元統綜的形式,「形神生滅論」作為當時流行的論爭,也不妨可視為是一種「複合式」的談題,它毋寧是前代諸名題相因下與佛教概念交涉、融通發展的結果。
Abstract
With the perspective of metaphysical discourses, this study investigates the influence mysterious learning and pure conversation exert on the issue of body and spirit’s appearance and disappearance in the Six Dynasties, and deepens understanding of related issues by exploring the contextual meaning of the successive ideas. The issue of body and spirit’s appearance and disappearance can be traced back to the no-ghost theory and the dream theory, whose body and spirit concepts are significant references for later discussions. For analyzing and thinking, the concepts of “root and branch, existence and nonexistence,” “views about nature,” “body and function” in mysterious learning are often the most frequently applied pattern. Therefore, just as pure conversation has diverse forms of development in the Southern Dynasties, the issue of body and spirit’s appearance and disappearance is also a composite thesis. It is the result of its former topics’ mutual integration and interaction with Buddhist concepts.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 臺大中文學報
- ISSN
- 1013-2422
- 卷期
- 45期
- 出版
- 2014年06月
- 頁碼
- 031–086
- 編號
- NTUEJ00007397
同期目錄
- 從商周人牲人殉論「始作俑者」的義涵李宗焜(Li Zong-Kun)・頁 001–030
- 六朝形神生滅論爭中的玄思綜論紀志昌(Chi Chih-Chang)・頁 031–086
- 從「自足於內」到「氣通內外」:阮德如與嵇康〈宅無吉凶攝生論〉等四篇試解吳冠宏(Wu Kuan-Hung)・頁 087–122
- 從擬篇法論陸機對南朝詩人的影響沈凡玉(Shen Fan-Yu)・頁 123–180
- 江聲、王鳴盛之輯佚思維及其輯《尚書》鄭《注》之若干重要問題洪博昇(Hung Po-Sheng)・頁 181–232
- 晚清詞學「溫柔敦厚」說之檢討陳水雲(Chen Shui-Yun)・頁 233–268
- 感傷的力量:林覺民〈與妻訣別書〉的正典化歷程與社會文化意義潘少瑜(Shaw-Yu Pan)・頁 269–322