The Role of Public International Law in Integrating Human Rights Considerations in Investment Treaty Arbitration
RegNet, Australian National University
摘要
In investment treaty arbitration, the respondent states have been increasingly raising the defences that the impugned measures were adopted to fulfill and protect that state’s human rights obligations or that the conduct of the investors had infringed on the human rights of their local population. Controversies arise as to how to reconcile the tensions between investment protection and public interests, particularly where the language of underlying investment treaties keeps silent on this matter.
This article explores the role of “public international law” in providing “affirmative defences” for the host state in investment treaty arbitration, bridging the normative divide between investment protection and human rights. Specifically, it delves into the application of the doctrines of police powers and contributory fault as judicial tools for tribunals to accommodate public interests or give effect to investor misconduct with respect to human rights. These notable instances reveal the potentials of public international law in integrating human rights considerations in investor-state treaty arbitration, thereby reconciling the normative conflicts between competing public and private interests.
Abstract
In investment treaty arbitration, the respondent states have been increasingly raising the defences that the impugned measures were adopted to fulfill and protect that state’s human rights obligations or that the conduct of the investors had infringed on the human rights of their local population. Controversies arise as to how to reconcile the tensions between investment protection and public interests, particularly where the language of underlying investment treaties keeps silent on this matter.
This article explores the role of “public international law” in providing “affirmative defences” for the host state in investment treaty arbitration, bridging the normative divide between investment protection and human rights. Specifically, it delves into the application of the doctrines of police powers and contributory fault as judicial tools for tribunals to accommodate public interests or give effect to investor misconduct with respect to human rights. These notable instances reveal the potentials of public international law in integrating human rights considerations in investor-state treaty arbitration, thereby reconciling the normative conflicts between competing public and private interests.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 16卷2期
- 出版
- 2021年09月
- 頁碼
- 275–328
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000074
同期目錄
- From Addressing Trade Distortion to Correcting Environmental Distortion: The Fisheries Subsidies Negotiation as the Turning Point of the WTO’s TaskChang-fa Lo & Tang-Kai Wang・頁 153–178
- Steel Overcapacity and the Global Trading SystemSherzod Shadikhodjaev・頁 179–218
- Will China Redefine International Trade Norms?Qingjiang Kong & Li Chen・頁 219–248
- Pandemics, Travel Restrictions, and the Distancing from International LawFernando Dias Simões・頁 249–274
- The Role of Public International Law in Integrating Human Rights Considerations in Investment Treaty ArbitrationRaymond Yang Gao・頁 275–328
- The Interaction Between Adjudicators and Legislative States Behind the Balancing Analysis in International Trade Law and Investment LawYing-Jun Lin・頁 329–368
- Reinforcing Dispute Settlement Mechanism Under the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control as an Option to Solve Trade/Investment-Related Tobacco DisputesPei-kan Yang・頁 369–392
- Establishing Extraterritorial Jurisdiction of Home State for Investor Accountability: English and Dutch Anchoring Mechanism and an IIA Complement or AlternativeLiping Huang・頁 393–420
- International Food Law: Historical Development and Need of Comprehensive LawSadiya S. Silvee & Ximei Wu・頁 421–461