江聲、王鳴盛之輯佚思維及其輯《尚書》鄭《注》之若干重要問題
Jiang Sheng and Wang Ming-Sheng’s Attitudes toward Scattered Document Compilation and Important Issues of Their Compilations of Zheng Xuan’s Annotations on the Book of Documents
世新大學中國文學系博士生(Ph.D Student, Department of Chinese Literature, Shih Hsin University.)
摘要
江聲、王鳴盛為乾嘉時期吳派代表之學者,二家於經學上咸以《尚書》名家,其治經皆以鄭學為宗,為清代中葉《古文尚書》學之代表。然而細究二家著作,對鄭《注》之輯佚,乃至於觀念及詮釋上,或有不同之處。本文認為,二家在治經觀念之歧異,影響了各自著作之面貌,故雖同為鄭學,呈現之內容亦有差別。本文所作,即以《尚書集注音疏》、《尚書後案》所輯之鄭《注》為研究對象,以見二家輯佚內容、方法、觀念之異同,以期作為日後研究江、王《尚書》學之基礎。
Abstract
Scholars Jiang Sheng and Wang Ming-Sheng are representative of the Wu School during the reigns of emperors Qianlong and Jiaqing. When studying the Book of Documents they both advocate the Old Text version and follow Zheng Xuan’s interpretation. However, this study finds that their works demonstrate separate concepts for compiling and interpreting Zheng’s annotations and infers that the two scholars have different attitudes that influence their works. By comparing the contents, methods, and concepts of their compilations of Zheng’s annotations on the Book of Documents with Collected Annotations and Pronunciation Annotations and Commentary on the Book of Documents, this study provides reference for future research on Jiang’s and Wang’s interpretations of the Book of Documents.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 臺大中文學報
- ISSN
- 1013-2422
- 卷期
- 45期
- 出版
- 2014年06月
- 頁碼
- 181–232
- 編號
- NTUEJ00007400
同期目錄
- 從商周人牲人殉論「始作俑者」的義涵李宗焜(Li Zong-Kun)・頁 001–030
- 六朝形神生滅論爭中的玄思綜論紀志昌(Chi Chih-Chang)・頁 031–086
- 從「自足於內」到「氣通內外」:阮德如與嵇康〈宅無吉凶攝生論〉等四篇試解吳冠宏(Wu Kuan-Hung)・頁 087–122
- 從擬篇法論陸機對南朝詩人的影響沈凡玉(Shen Fan-Yu)・頁 123–180
- 江聲、王鳴盛之輯佚思維及其輯《尚書》鄭《注》之若干重要問題洪博昇(Hung Po-Sheng)・頁 181–232
- 晚清詞學「溫柔敦厚」說之檢討陳水雲(Chen Shui-Yun)・頁 233–268
- 感傷的力量:林覺民〈與妻訣別書〉的正典化歷程與社會文化意義潘少瑜(Shaw-Yu Pan)・頁 269–322