洪良品的古文《尚書》辨真理論
Hong Liang-Pin’s Theory of Authenticating Old Text Shang Shu
國立臺灣大學中國文學系助理教授(Assistant Professor, Department of Chinese Literature, National Taiwan University.)
摘要
受清末至民初逐漸形成,並廣泛為學人強調的科學精神及方法之影響,今人對清代《尚書》學的關注,集中於與辨偽相關的成就,而忽略晚清《尚書》學可能的多面性,尤其是持論與辨偽相反的,對《尚書》古文諸篇之辨真相關著作。本文試圖回到清代的學術背景,考察《尚書》學的發展,並以成書時間較晩、資料蒐羅較齊備的洪良品為例,分析其對古文諸篇的辨真理論,同時與辨偽者之重要論點及考辨方法相比較,一方面打破既有看待清代《尚書》學的視野,而以較寬廣的角度,探討《尚書》學於晚清的發展情形;一方面藉由雙方論證方法之比較,提供觀察辨真及辨偽觀點的另一個視角。二者皆有助於吾人對清代學術史的建構與解讀。
Abstract
Contemporary Sang-shu(尚書) research, affected by the scientific spirit and method emphasized by scholars from the beginning of the Republican period, has tended to focus on the fruits of bian-wei(辨偽). This has unfortunately led to a relative ignorance of the possible diversity present in late Qing dynasty Sang-shu studies, especially the works concerning bian-zhen(辨真), which take the opposite view of bian-wei. To approach this lack in scholarship, this paper attempts to return to the background of the Qing intellectual environment to observe the development of Sang-shu studies. I take Hong Liang-pin’s(洪良品) works as my main example since they were completed later and integrate numerous materials. I then compare them with bian-wei works. In this way, I hope to break through the recent views of Qing dynasty Sang-shu studies, and see its development from a wider angle to provide a new point of view from which to observe the bian-zhen and bian-wei debate. Together this will help us better construct and understand Qing intellectual history.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 臺大中文學報
- ISSN
- 1013-2422
- 卷期
- 42期
- 出版
- 2013年10月
- 頁碼
- 155–202
- 編號
- NTUEJ00007416
同期目錄
- 論《論語》中孔子所體現的「心之無對性」徐聖心(Hsu Sheng-Hsin)・頁 001–052
- 《左傳》「郭」、「郛」考黃聖松(Huang Sheng-Sung)・頁 053–112
- 《毛詩李黃集解》析論──以書寫體例與解釋方法為考察中心黃忠慎(Huang Chung-Shen)・頁 113–154
- 洪良品的古文《尚書》辨真理論曹美秀(Tsao Mei-Hsiu)・頁 155–202
- 魯迅《漢武故事》輯本訂補賴信宏(Lai Sin-Hung)・頁 203–234