鄭玄《三禮注》「之言」訓詁術語析論──兼論其術語意義之演變
The Scholium Term Zhi-Yan in Zheng Xuan’s Annotations on the Three Rites, and the Development of Zhi-Yan’s Meaning as a Scholium Term
國立臺灣大學中國文學系副教授(Associate Professor, Department of Chinese Literature, National Taiwan University.)
摘要
「之言」一直被視為探求語源的訓詁術語,然而經由本文對鄭玄《三禮注》「之言」術語所作的分析發現:《周禮注》沿襲傳統用法,以推源為主,偶或釋義;《禮記注》已漸轉化,推源及釋義並用;其後至《毛詩箋》則轉以釋義為主。可見鄭氏訓詁由兼具語源學推源及訓詁學釋義的雙重觀念,逐漸趨向以訓詁學釋義的觀念為主。
鄭氏「之言」涵義之演變,對其術語的發展具承先啟後之影響。蓋自《孟子》首開以「之言」正名之例,漢代董仲舒進而將正名主義的聲訓帶入顛峰,今文學與讖緯聲訓蠭出;《說文》及《釋名》等字典類專著,使聲訓逐漸走向探源的純語源學方向;鄭玄《注》、《箋》則在日趨訓詁學釋義的觀念下,漸次將「之言」、聲訓轉化為釋義為主,並成為後世訓詁學的主流。
Abstract
The word zhi-yan has been regarded as a scholium term to indicate the origin of a Chinese character, but this study makes a new discovery after analyzing the zhi-yan in Zheng Xuan’s Annotations on the Three Rites. In the Annotations on the Rites of Zhou, Zheng follows the traditional method of using it mostly to trace word origins and occasionally to explain word meanings. In the Annotations on the Book of Rites, it is equally used for word origins and word meanings; in the Annotations on the Mao Poetry, it is mainly used to explain word meanings. Clearly, Zheng Xuan first uses zhi-yan etymologically but in the end explanatorily.
Zheng Xuan’s zhi-yan is a turning point in the development of Chinese terminology. The term is firstly used to rectify word meanings in the Mengzi, and this usage prevails most when Dong Zhong-Shu’s emphasis on sound glosses leads to the prosperity of New Texts studies and text divination. Then dictionaries such as the Explaining and Analyzing Characters and the Explaining Names use it to describe word origins instead. Under the influence of Zheng Xuan’s annotations, zhi-yan is gradually used to explain word meanings, and this usage later becomes the mainstream of scholium studies.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- 臺大中文學報
- ISSN
- 1013-2422
- 卷期
- 41期
- 出版
- 2013年06月
- 頁碼
- 033–084
- 編號
- NTUEJ00007419
同期目錄
- 黃組卜辭綴合十六則張宇衛(Chang Yu-Wei)・頁 001–032
- 鄭玄《三禮注》「之言」訓詁術語析論──兼論其術語意義之演變劉文清(Liu Wen-Ching)・頁 033–084
- 毀滅的城市:論南朝辭賦中的城市書寫與毀滅敘事祁立峰(Chi Li-Feng)・頁 085–124
- 《中原音韻》「的本」與「翻切圈註」本考辨──兼談對元明填詞度曲之意義李惠綿(Li Huei-Mian)・頁 125–176
- 晚明「情種」說之文化意涵及多重向度黃莘瑜(Huang Sin-Yu)・頁 177–224
- 《聊齋誌異》的仙凡流轉:劉、阮再返之思與情緣道念之辨陳翠英(Chen Chui-Ying)・頁 225–276
- 刻在石上的遺民史:《宋臺秋唱》與香港遺民地景高嘉謙(Ko Chia-Cian)・頁 277–316