《毛詩箋》「之言」術語析論
Terminology Analysis on Zhiyan in Maoshijian
國立臺灣大學中國文學系Department of Chinese Literature, National Taiwan University.
摘要
「之言」一直被訓詁家視為探求語源的術語,然經由本文對鄭玄《毛詩箋》「之言」術語所作的統計分析發現,其術語之施用範圍雖遍及於語源、同源字、轉注字或轉語、假借字、以本字為訓、合音字等項,然主要作用在於文本釋義,偶或探源。揆其緣由,一則因鄭《箋》本為「隨文釋義」的訓詁專書,故其術語之運用主要出於訓詁學釋義的觀念。再則或受毛《傳》等訓詁家樸學的影響,而將《三禮注》中推源為主的「之言」術語轉化為釋義為主。
自《毛詩箋》之後,「之言」術語由探源而釋義的消長之勢已然形成,從而影響後世訓詁家之運用「之言」術語、甚至聲訓,大多以釋義為主,可見鄭學影響之深遠。
Abstract
While scholiasts usually define zhiyan (之言) as a term used to indicate the origin of a Chinese character, this study makes a different discovery with a statistical analysis of zhiyan in Maoshijian (《毛詩箋》) of Zheng Xuan (鄭玄). Though zhiyan may indicate the origins of characters, cognates (同源字), Zhuan Zhu characters (轉注字), derivative cognates (轉語), Jia Jie characters (假借字), original characters for glosses (以本字為訓), and combined-syllable characters (合音字), its primary function is to elaborate the meanings of texts, and only occasionally is it applied to origins of characters. This is because of two reasons. First, since Maoshijian is a scholiastic book, the application of zhiyan is derived from the concept of scholium. Second, zhiyan in Zheng’s Sanlizhu (《三禮注》) is applied to origins of characters, but afterward it is applied to the meanings under the influence of Mao’s Chuan (毛《傳》).
Since the publication of Maoshijian, zhiyan has officially become a term applied to meanings of texts, causing the scholiasts of following generations to use zhiyan and even sound glosses (聲訓) to indicate meanings. This transformation shows the profound significance of Zheng Xuan’s doctrine.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大中文學報
- ISSN
- 1013-2422
- 卷期
- 35期
- 出版
- 2011年12月
- 頁碼
- 001–042
- 編號
- NTUEJ00007462
同期目錄
- 《毛詩箋》「之言」術語析論劉文清(Liu Wen-Ching)・頁 001–042
- 道統意識與德行論述:荀子非難思、孟的旨趣重探伍振勳(Wu Zhen-Xun)・頁 043–084
- 江南境物與壺中天地──白居易履道園的收藏美學曹淑娟(Tsao Shu-Chuan)・頁 085–124
- 延滯與替代:論《西遊補》的自我顛覆敘事許暉林(Hsu Hui-Lin)・頁 125–156
- 論《紅樓夢》中「情理兼備」而「兩盡其道」之「痴理」觀歐麗娟(Ou Li-Chuan)・頁 157–204
- 清代學者「禮書」復仇觀的省察與詮釋李隆獻(Lee Long-Shien)・頁 205–246
- 卡內提的孔子論述張堯欽(Chang Yau-Chin)・頁 247–288
- 楊牧的戲劇獨白體劉正忠(Liu Zheng-Zhong)・頁 289–328
- 臺北市泉腔閩南語央元音的變異與變化陳淑娟(Chen, Shu-Chuan)、杜佳倫(Tu, Chia-Lun)・頁 329–370