《碧琳琅館叢書》本《金氏尚書注》著者考疑
An Investigation into the Authenticity of the Bi-Lin-Lang-Guan Version of Jin Lu-Xiang’s Shang Shu Zhu
國立臺灣大學中國文學系Department of Chinese Literature, National Taiwan University.
摘要
金履祥為宋、元之際經學大家,據載金氏關於《尚書》的作品有《尚書表注》一卷、《尚書注》十二卷,又嘗以《尚書》為主,旁採經子諸說,作《通鑑前編》十二卷。近人蔡根祥曾考證其十二卷《尚書注》,當是由《通鑑前編》中將關於《尚書》部份的文字輯出而成,乃後人偽作。不過,事實上今日傳世的金履祥《尚書注》有兩種版本,一為陸心源《十萬卷樓叢書》本,此為流行本,一本則收入清人方功惠《碧琳琅館叢書》當中。兩書內容完全不同,然大部份學者均未詳加分別,以為同本。本文試圖就此一發現發現,由既有文獻資料,整理關於金履祥《尚書注》的歷來著作情形,並對《碧琳琅館叢書》本《金氏尚書注》內容作詳細的探討。經研究後,發現此書的思想、內容均與金履祥時代不合,再進一步考察,得知此本亦是偽作,為後人取元人陳師凱《書蔡傳旁通》為主,並用及相關資料作為〈序〉、〈跋〉、〈附錄〉拼湊而成,當是清代中葉之後的人所偽作。
Abstract
Jin Lu-Xiang is an important scholar in the Sung and the Yuan Dynasties. Allegedly, he is the author of Shang Shu Biao Zhu (Commentaries on the Chronicle in Shang Shu), Shang Shu Zhu (Commentaries on Shang Shu), and Zi Zhi Tong Jian Qian Bian (The History before Zi Zhi Tong Jian). Recently, Tsai Ken-Hsian has found out that Shang Shu Zhu is a fake: it is actually a part of Zi Zhi Tong Jian Qian Bian.
We currently have 2 versions of Jin’s Shang Shu Zhu, one of which is in Lu Xin-Yuan’s Shi-Wan-Juan-Lou Series and the other one is in Fang Gong-Hui’s Bi-Ling-Lang-Guan Series. These 2 versions are totally different, but few scholars have discovered this fact.
With a detailed investigation into all the documents related to Jin’s writing process of Shang Shu Zhu, this study proves that the Bi-Ling-Lang-Guan version is also a fake, because the thoughts that it includes do not exist in Jin’s time. This version is actually Chen Shi-Kai’s Shu Tsai Zhuan Pang Tong in the Yuan Dynasty, combined with related information as its preface, postscript, and appendix. It has been fabricated in the middle period of the Qing Dynasty.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大中文學報
- ISSN
- 1013-2422
- 卷期
- 34期
- 出版
- 2011年06月
- 頁碼
- 229–262
- 編號
- NTUEJ00007476
同期目錄
- 「守靜督」與「緣督以為經」──一條體現《老》、《莊》之學的身體技術蔡璧名(Tsai Bi-Ming)・頁 001–054
- 戰國楚簡異體字類型舉隅──以上博楚竹書為中心徐富昌(Hsu Fu-Chang)・頁 055–092
- 桓譚見知著述探攷周大任(Zhou Da-Ren)・頁 093–136
- 論鮑照仿古樂府詩的文類慣例與風格特性──由篇題有無「代」字的區辨述起李錫鎮(Lee Hsi-Chen)・頁 137–182
- 黃庭堅與寒山詩關係考陳英傑(Chen Ying-Chieh)・頁 183–228
- 《碧琳琅館叢書》本《金氏尚書注》著者考疑許育龍(Hsu Yu-Lung)・頁 229–262
- 刁包《易》學的思想基礎及治《易》立場與作法楊自平(Yang Tzu-Ping)・頁 263–304
- 「發六百年來儒林所不及知者」——全祖望續補《宋元學案》的學術史意義夏長樸(Hsia Chang-Pwu)・頁 305–348
- 「無花空折枝」——《紅樓夢》中的迎春、惜春探論歐麗娟(Ou Li-Chuan)・頁 349–394
- 漢語語音史中的擦音聲母李存智(Lee Chun-Chih)・頁 395–466