The Interaction Between Adjudicators and Legislative States Behind the Balancing Analysis in International Trade Law and Investment Law
School of Law, Chungyuan Christian University, Taiwan
摘要
The balancing analysis, an interpretative approach and principle that emerged in World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”) dispute settlements and investor-State arbitration, has been observed as the convergence between international trade law and investment law. International lawyers value the balancing analysis as an instrument for international adjudicators to reconcile competing interests and respect states’ right to regulate. Accordingly, many studies have been explored the convergence and divergence of the balancing from the normative perspective. This article, however, aims to contribute to the studies of the balancing analysis from the institutional perspective. Two issues reflect the institutional perspective: how do international adjudicators react to the textual arrangements through the balancing analysis? Moreover, what consequences would be caused by how adjudicators employed the balancing analysis to react to the decisions of legislative States embodied in a treaty? Through the two issues, the article observes that the more ambiguous the intention of reconciling competing interests and policy purposes in a treaty, the more efforts international adjudicators need to devote to interpreting the textual grounds for the balancing analysis. In identifying the textual grounds for the balancing analysis, however, international adjudicators are at the risk of adjusting the textual arrangement and political decisions made by the legislative States. That is the situation that arbitrators of investor-State arbitration confronted. Therefore, the article argues that the balancing analysis may increase the tension between adjudicative bodies and legislative States while it is helpful to restore regulatory autonomy for the exercising States. The perspective of adjudicators reacting to the political decisions by States provides insights into the application of interpretative approaches in different regimes. Moreover, the struggle of determining the scope of the adjudicative authority in the textual grounds of WTO Agreements and investment treaties sheds light on the way to discuss the relationship between the states’ consent and the decision by international adjudicators.
Abstract
The balancing analysis, an interpretative approach and principle that emerged in World Trade Organization (hereinafter “WTO”) dispute settlements and investor-State arbitration, has been observed as the convergence between international trade law and investment law. International lawyers value the balancing analysis as an instrument for international adjudicators to reconcile competing interests and respect states’ right to regulate. Accordingly, many studies have been explored the convergence and divergence of the balancing from the normative perspective. This article, however, aims to contribute to the studies of the balancing analysis from the institutional perspective. Two issues reflect the institutional perspective: how do international adjudicators react to the textual arrangements through the balancing analysis? Moreover, what consequences would be caused by how adjudicators employed the balancing analysis to react to the decisions of legislative States embodied in a treaty? Through the two issues, the article observes that the more ambiguous the intention of reconciling competing interests and policy purposes in a treaty, the more efforts international adjudicators need to devote to interpreting the textual grounds for the balancing analysis. In identifying the textual grounds for the balancing analysis, however, international adjudicators are at the risk of adjusting the textual arrangement and political decisions made by the legislative States. That is the situation that arbitrators of investor-State arbitration confronted. Therefore, the article argues that the balancing analysis may increase the tension between adjudicative bodies and legislative States while it is helpful to restore regulatory autonomy for the exercising States. The perspective of adjudicators reacting to the political decisions by States provides insights into the application of interpretative approaches in different regimes. Moreover, the struggle of determining the scope of the adjudicative authority in the textual grounds of WTO Agreements and investment treaties sheds light on the way to discuss the relationship between the states’ consent and the decision by international adjudicators.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 16卷2期
- 出版
- 2021年09月
- 頁碼
- 329–368
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000075
同期目錄
- From Addressing Trade Distortion to Correcting Environmental Distortion: The Fisheries Subsidies Negotiation as the Turning Point of the WTO’s TaskChang-fa Lo & Tang-Kai Wang・頁 153–178
- Steel Overcapacity and the Global Trading SystemSherzod Shadikhodjaev・頁 179–218
- Will China Redefine International Trade Norms?Qingjiang Kong & Li Chen・頁 219–248
- Pandemics, Travel Restrictions, and the Distancing from International LawFernando Dias Simões・頁 249–274
- The Role of Public International Law in Integrating Human Rights Considerations in Investment Treaty ArbitrationRaymond Yang Gao・頁 275–328
- The Interaction Between Adjudicators and Legislative States Behind the Balancing Analysis in International Trade Law and Investment LawYing-Jun Lin・頁 329–368
- Reinforcing Dispute Settlement Mechanism Under the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control as an Option to Solve Trade/Investment-Related Tobacco DisputesPei-kan Yang・頁 369–392
- Establishing Extraterritorial Jurisdiction of Home State for Investor Accountability: English and Dutch Anchoring Mechanism and an IIA Complement or AlternativeLiping Huang・頁 393–420
- International Food Law: Historical Development and Need of Comprehensive LawSadiya S. Silvee & Ximei Wu・頁 421–461