臺大學術期刊資料庫NTU Journal Database

對反或連續:王弼與郭象思想的爭議

Conflict or Continuity: A Dispute over the Thought of Wang Bi and Guo Xiang

蔡振豐(Tsai Chen-Feng)

國立臺灣大學中國文學系(Department of Chinese Literature, National Taiwan University)

卷期
24期
出版
2006年06月
頁碼
083–114
編號
NTUEJ00007560
僅書目本篇只提供書目資料,資料庫沒有電子全文。

需要全文時,可以向出版單位洽詢,聯絡方式見期刊資訊。

摘要

王弼與郭象的思想究竟是「貴無」與「崇有」二個對反的敵論?或者道家內部思想的連續發展?是魏晉玄學史中一個爭議性的問題。本文由三個方向重新討論此一問題。一是王弼「以無為本」與郭象的「造物無主」是一個爭議論形上實體是否存在的問題或是對道家所論之「無」與「自然」的詮釋學問題?二是郭象的「寄言出意」說是否純粹指為由「言」得到「言外之意」?它與王弼的語言詮釋觀有何關係?透過對這二個問題的討論,本文的結論以為;王弼與郭象的思想並不具對反性,二者的思想具有連續的性質,可相互補充而形成一個具有不同層次的完整論述,而且王弼與郭象的詮釋取向,也已內存於《老子》與《莊子》的文本之中。

Abstract

The question of whether the thought of Wang Bi (王弼) and Guo Xiang (郭象) should be seen as belonging to the two very opposed ideas of gui wu (貴無 , emphasizing nothingness) and chung you (崇有 , glorifying being) or whether, taken together, they represent a continuous, internal develop-ment in Taoist thought is one of the most thorny problems in the history of the metaphysics of the Wei and Jin periods. This paper takes a new look at this problem from two perspectives. The first asks whether Wang's yi wu wei ben (以無為本 , taking nothingness as a basis) and Guo's zao wu wu zhu (造物無主 , in the making of things there is no creator) are two competing answers to the question of whether a metaphysical entity exists or an attempt to resolve the hermeneutical problem of how to interpret wu (無 , nothingness) and ziran (自然 , natural) in Taoism. The second asks whether Guo's formulation ji yan chu yi (寄言出意 , embedding meaning in words) implies a special hermeneutical perspective and what its relation with Wang's view of the hermeneutics of language is. By discussing these two issues, this paper shows that the thought of Wang Bi and Guo Xiang is not contradictory but rather represents a continued development and that the two complement each other to make up a complete discourse, albeit on two different levels. At the same time, we see that the hermeneutical leanings of Wang Bi and Guo Xian draw on the texts of the Laozi and the Chuangzi.

關鍵詞

程式與 AI 助手可以改用資料介面(JSON、MCP),查詢比讀頁面快。給程式與 AI 代理的存取說明