Reinforcing Dispute Settlement Mechanism Under the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control as an Option to Solve Trade/Investment-Related Tobacco Disputes
Department of International Business, College of Commerce, National Chengchi University, Taipei, Taiwan
摘要
The liberalization of international trade in tobacco products has been criticized for the spread of tobacco epidemics worldwide. Tobacco control policies have been legally challenged for violations of international trade and investment agreements. Trade and investment issues have long been one of the controversies fiercely debated among delegates of the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (hereinafter “FCTC”) since the initiation of negotiation in 1999, and continue to be an issue in relation to the implementation of the FCTC since its entering into force in 2005. The tobacco-related dispute settlement mechanism and its relationship with other trade or investment dispute settlement mechanisms remains one of the significant issues due to the potential impacts of such trade or investment rulings on the formation and implementation of tobacco control policies. With a brief overview of how international trade issues evolved under the FCTC, this paper focuses on the examination of problems of current dispute settlement provision (namely Article 27) of the FCTC. While the use of Article 27 dispute settlement mechanism has limited implications for initiation of a trade or investment dispute, establishing an enhanced ad hoc arbitration mechanism avails Parties to the FCTC an alternative forum for solving tobacco disputes within the realm of the international health law. This paper explores possible options for the reinforcement of the current system to encourage the use of a pro-health settlement of tobacco disputes under the FCTC.
Abstract
The liberalization of international trade in tobacco products has been criticized for the spread of tobacco epidemics worldwide. Tobacco control policies have been legally challenged for violations of international trade and investment agreements. Trade and investment issues have long been one of the controversies fiercely debated among delegates of the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (hereinafter “FCTC”) since the initiation of negotiation in 1999, and continue to be an issue in relation to the implementation of the FCTC since its entering into force in 2005. The tobacco-related dispute settlement mechanism and its relationship with other trade or investment dispute settlement mechanisms remains one of the significant issues due to the potential impacts of such trade or investment rulings on the formation and implementation of tobacco control policies. With a brief overview of how international trade issues evolved under the FCTC, this paper focuses on the examination of problems of current dispute settlement provision (namely Article 27) of the FCTC. While the use of Article 27 dispute settlement mechanism has limited implications for initiation of a trade or investment dispute, establishing an enhanced ad hoc arbitration mechanism avails Parties to the FCTC an alternative forum for solving tobacco disputes within the realm of the international health law. This paper explores possible options for the reinforcement of the current system to encourage the use of a pro-health settlement of tobacco disputes under the FCTC.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 16卷2期
- 出版
- 2021年09月
- 頁碼
- 369–392
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000076
同期目錄
- From Addressing Trade Distortion to Correcting Environmental Distortion: The Fisheries Subsidies Negotiation as the Turning Point of the WTO’s TaskChang-fa Lo & Tang-Kai Wang・頁 153–178
- Steel Overcapacity and the Global Trading SystemSherzod Shadikhodjaev・頁 179–218
- Will China Redefine International Trade Norms?Qingjiang Kong & Li Chen・頁 219–248
- Pandemics, Travel Restrictions, and the Distancing from International LawFernando Dias Simões・頁 249–274
- The Role of Public International Law in Integrating Human Rights Considerations in Investment Treaty ArbitrationRaymond Yang Gao・頁 275–328
- The Interaction Between Adjudicators and Legislative States Behind the Balancing Analysis in International Trade Law and Investment LawYing-Jun Lin・頁 329–368
- Reinforcing Dispute Settlement Mechanism Under the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control as an Option to Solve Trade/Investment-Related Tobacco DisputesPei-kan Yang・頁 369–392
- Establishing Extraterritorial Jurisdiction of Home State for Investor Accountability: English and Dutch Anchoring Mechanism and an IIA Complement or AlternativeLiping Huang・頁 393–420
- International Food Law: Historical Development and Need of Comprehensive LawSadiya S. Silvee & Ximei Wu・頁 421–461