Establishing Extraterritorial Jurisdiction of Home State for Investor Accountability: English and Dutch Anchoring Mechanism and an IIA Complement or Alternative
Faculty of Law, South China University of Technology
摘要
There is an international trend of holding investors liable through the judicial process of home states for their infringements committed in host states. In such civil proceedings, English and Dutch courts adopted an anchoring mechanism for jurisdictional issues, from which lessons can be learned by other investors’ home state courts. However, there are problems with its legal basis. Firstly, it relies upon the “Brussels Regulation” which should not be applicable to cases concerning the jurisdiction of non-EU states. Even assuming that it is applicable, the English anchoring mechanism now faces a renewed “forum non conveniens” challenge with Brexit. Compared to the English “necessary or proper party” gateway, the Dutch anchoring mechanism under Article 7(1) of the Dutch Code of Civil Procedure confuses the necessity of joint consideration and the ground of extraterritorial jurisdiction, without any requirement of links between the forum state and the claims. This article advocates international investment agreements (hereinafter “IIAs”) provision on investor liability in the home state to complement or replace the anchoring mechanism, which can be justified as an analogy to an exceptional arrangement to territorial principle. The existing provision shall be improved, such as by taking the IIA with such a provision as part of the applicable laws and considering the application of home state laws, designating a specific home state court or adopting further junctions where domicile of defendant and place of tort are inapplicable, and clarifying plaintiff qualification based on victims of investor infringements.
Abstract
There is an international trend of holding investors liable through the judicial process of home states for their infringements committed in host states. In such civil proceedings, English and Dutch courts adopted an anchoring mechanism for jurisdictional issues, from which lessons can be learned by other investors’ home state courts. However, there are problems with its legal basis. Firstly, it relies upon the “Brussels Regulation” which should not be applicable to cases concerning the jurisdiction of non-EU states. Even assuming that it is applicable, the English anchoring mechanism now faces a renewed “forum non conveniens” challenge with Brexit. Compared to the English “necessary or proper party” gateway, the Dutch anchoring mechanism under Article 7(1) of the Dutch Code of Civil Procedure confuses the necessity of joint consideration and the ground of extraterritorial jurisdiction, without any requirement of links between the forum state and the claims. This article advocates international investment agreements (hereinafter “IIAs”) provision on investor liability in the home state to complement or replace the anchoring mechanism, which can be justified as an analogy to an exceptional arrangement to territorial principle. The existing provision shall be improved, such as by taking the IIA with such a provision as part of the applicable laws and considering the application of home state laws, designating a specific home state court or adopting further junctions where domicile of defendant and place of tort are inapplicable, and clarifying plaintiff qualification based on victims of investor infringements.
關鍵詞
- 類型
- 論文
- 期刊
- Asian Journal of WTO & International Health Law and policy
- ISSN
- 1819-5164
- 卷期
- 16卷2期
- 出版
- 2021年09月
- 頁碼
- 393–420
- 編號
- NTUEJ00000077
同期目錄
- From Addressing Trade Distortion to Correcting Environmental Distortion: The Fisheries Subsidies Negotiation as the Turning Point of the WTO’s TaskChang-fa Lo & Tang-Kai Wang・頁 153–178
- Steel Overcapacity and the Global Trading SystemSherzod Shadikhodjaev・頁 179–218
- Will China Redefine International Trade Norms?Qingjiang Kong & Li Chen・頁 219–248
- Pandemics, Travel Restrictions, and the Distancing from International LawFernando Dias Simões・頁 249–274
- The Role of Public International Law in Integrating Human Rights Considerations in Investment Treaty ArbitrationRaymond Yang Gao・頁 275–328
- The Interaction Between Adjudicators and Legislative States Behind the Balancing Analysis in International Trade Law and Investment LawYing-Jun Lin・頁 329–368
- Reinforcing Dispute Settlement Mechanism Under the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control as an Option to Solve Trade/Investment-Related Tobacco DisputesPei-kan Yang・頁 369–392
- Establishing Extraterritorial Jurisdiction of Home State for Investor Accountability: English and Dutch Anchoring Mechanism and an IIA Complement or AlternativeLiping Huang・頁 393–420
- International Food Law: Historical Development and Need of Comprehensive LawSadiya S. Silvee & Ximei Wu・頁 421–461