Vedic Antecedents to Buddhist Mythology: Tvaṣṭṛ’s Cup, the Ṛbhus, and the Third Pressing in Comparison to the Several Myths of the Buddha’s Bowls
Assistant Professor in the Department of English, National Central University.
摘要
Several narratives concerning the Buddha’s sacred bowls in relatively
early Buddhist texts can be read against the backdrop of a set of
mythological paradigms from the Vedas and its concomitant ritual
practices. I connect the controversial Vedic mythology of Tvaṣṭṛ’s
unique soma cup, its multiplication into four cups by the Ṛbhus, and
the invention of the Third Pressing—myths that are only narrativized
in the earliest Vedic texts—to two myths, already present in nuce
in the oldest Buddhist texts, but then more fully narrativized in the
Pāli Nidānakathā—in which the Buddha receives special bowls:one bowl from a woman called Sujātā, and one bowl (originally
four) from the Lokapālas. Since the Vedic myths in question appear
virtually exclusively in the Ṛgveda and its Aitareya Brāhmaṇa,
before they appear to be forgotten along with their internal tensions
regarding the democratization of sacrifice, I argue that the significantly
later Buddhist texts are in effect cutting across a set of established
orthodoxies in the contemporary Brahmanical traditions, wherein,
we will see, there is clear evidence that the tensions surrounding
the Ṛbhus had long been resolved. Thus, the Buddhist authors
appear to have reached back into the storehouse of recondite Vedic
mythology in order to reopen an ancient set of tensions concerning
the democratization of religious practices that is then adapted to give
a specific weight to this important moment in the life of the Buddha.
I will argue that they do so both to ground themselves in that ancient
tradition and to also differentiate Buddhist mythology from that of its
Brahmanical contemporaries. In conclude by observing that at times
the Buddhist texts thus attempt to be hyper-Vedic in their negative
acculturation from their contemporaries. This conclusion, and the
methodological profile of the article, invites scholars to raise broader
questions about the comparative mythology of Buddhist materials to
their sources—specifically to those sources that might otherwise seem
historically out of reach, but which have left a clear imprint in the
formation of stories about the life of the Buddha.
Abstract
Several narratives concerning the Buddha’s sacred bowls in relatively
early Buddhist texts can be read against the backdrop of a set of
mythological paradigms from the Vedas and its concomitant ritual
practices. I connect the controversial Vedic mythology of Tvaṣṭṛ’s
unique soma cup, its multiplication into four cups by the Ṛbhus, and
the invention of the Third Pressing—myths that are only narrativized
in the earliest Vedic texts—to two myths, already present in nuce
in the oldest Buddhist texts, but then more fully narrativized in the
Pāli Nidānakathā—in which the Buddha receives special bowls:one bowl from a woman called Sujātā, and one bowl (originally
four) from the Lokapālas. Since the Vedic myths in question appear
virtually exclusively in the Ṛgveda and its Aitareya Brāhmaṇa,
before they appear to be forgotten along with their internal tensions
regarding the democratization of sacrifice, I argue that the significantly
later Buddhist texts are in effect cutting across a set of established
orthodoxies in the contemporary Brahmanical traditions, wherein,
we will see, there is clear evidence that the tensions surrounding
the Ṛbhus had long been resolved. Thus, the Buddhist authors
appear to have reached back into the storehouse of recondite Vedic
mythology in order to reopen an ancient set of tensions concerning
the democratization of religious practices that is then adapted to give
a specific weight to this important moment in the life of the Buddha.
I will argue that they do so both to ground themselves in that ancient
tradition and to also differentiate Buddhist mythology from that of its
Brahmanical contemporaries. In conclude by observing that at times
the Buddhist texts thus attempt to be hyper-Vedic in their negative
acculturation from their contemporaries. This conclusion, and the
methodological profile of the article, invites scholars to raise broader
questions about the comparative mythology of Buddhist materials to
their sources—specifically to those sources that might otherwise seem
historically out of reach, but which have left a clear imprint in the
formation of stories about the life of the Buddha.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大佛學研究
- ISSN
- 1027-1112
- 卷期
- 49期
- 出版
- 2025年06月
- 頁碼
- 123–171
- 編號
- NTUEJ00007816
同期目錄
- 宋元禪僧語錄之偈頌所見雲遊活動及其文化意涵齊勝利;Shengli Qi・頁 1–60
- 以現代學科方法探究《攝類學命題的內涵中認識論與多重侯浩生;Hao-Sheng Hou・頁 61–121
- Vedic Antecedents to Buddhist Mythology: Tvaṣṭṛ’s Cup, the Ṛbhus, and the Third Pressing in Comparison to the Several Myths of the Buddha’s BowlsClaudio Sansone・頁 123–171