等流習氣與異熟習氣 —以《唯識三十頌》與《成唯識論》 為討論核心
The Interpretation of the Vāsanā of Homogeneous Cause and the Vāsanā of Maturation in the Triṃśikābhāṣya and the Chéng Wéi Shì Lùng
慕尼黑大學佛學研究博士;Dr.des. in the Buddhist Studies Program, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität
München.
摘要
熏習(vāsanā)一詞在各時期的大乘佛教唯識學派文本中指
稱不同的意義,其中可歸納為兩種主要意涵:存放在阿賴耶識中 的習氣,或具有熏習功能的動力。四世紀印度唯識學派建立者世 親在其《唯識三十論》內僅提出業習氣(karmavāsanā)與二取 習氣(grāhadvayavāsanā),描述阿賴耶識(ālayavijñāna)得
以投生至來世的原因。然而,六世紀印度唯識學者安慧註釋《唯 識三十頌》的 Triṃśikābhāṣya(TrBh)中,卻將習氣做為主要理 解識轉變(vijñānapariṇāma)和阿賴耶識轉生的關鍵,提出等 流習氣(niṣyandavāsanā)和異熟習氣(vipākavāsanā)。此二 習氣被唐代玄奘(602-664)糅譯印度諸論師註疏而成的《成唯 識論》中亦有提及。《成唯識論》將 vāsanā 一詞譯為熏習或習 氣,展現 vāsanā 具有多義性。
本文對比安慧 TrBh 和玄奘《成唯識論》中有關等流習氣和
異熟習氣的段落,發現 TrBh 使用 vāsanā 時,並未區分為習氣或
是熏習,而是同時指稱能被熏習的對象和可熏習對象的力。與此 不同,《成唯識論》則是將習氣等同於含藏在阿賴耶識中的種 子(bīja),熏習則是習氣力,可對下一剎那的生起產生作用。TrBh 未將等流與異熟習氣等同於《唯識三十頌》的業習氣與二
取習氣,表現出前者指涉識轉變,後者用於阿賴耶識轉生的立 場。TrBh 對於 vāsanā 的使用,展現出此一學說在印度唯識學派
中的多重意涵與獨立於種子學說之外的意義。而《成唯識論》中 的習氣/熏習二者,則是說明涵藏種子的阿賴耶識具有生起諸法 並投生下一世的動力。
Abstract
In the Indian Yogācāra school, the concept of vāsanā is a central teaching that holds considerable importance and encompasses multiple meanings. In the Triṃśikā (Tr), Vasubandhu (4th century) uses vāsanā to refer to the vāsanā of karman (karmavāsanā) and the vāsanā of twofold grasping (grāhadvayavāsanā), namely, the grasper (grāhya) and the grasped (grāhaka). However, in the Triṃśikābhāṣya (TrBh), a commentary on the Tr by Sthiramati (6th century), the concept of vāsanā appears more frequently. In the TrBh, Sthiramati introduces the vāsanā of maturation (vipākavāsanā) and the vāsanā of homogeneous cause (niṣyandavāsanā) to signify the process of conceptualization (vikalpa) within the ālayavijñāna and the future rebirth of ālayavijñāna. These two vāsanās also appear in the Chéng Wéi Shì Lùn (CWSL) of Xuánzàng (602-664), a translation of Indian commentaries on the Tr. Xuánzàng translates vāsanā as 熏習 (xūnxí) and 習氣 (xíqì) in the CWSL to distinguish the dynamic process of infusion from the impressions stored in the ālayavijñāna. This translation highlights the dual function of vāsanā as both noun and verb.
Remarkably, the concept of vāsanās shares a close relationship with that of bījas in the Yogācāra school. In the Tr, bīja refers to the potency stored in the ālayavijñāna, in which previous experiences are preserved in one’s mind and manifest in subsequent moments. Yet, in the TrBh, it is not the bīja but the vāsanā that can be passively infused by arising consciousnesses and stored in the ālayavijñāna. By juxtaposing the corresponding paragraphs from the TrBh and the CWSL, this paper investigates how the concept of vāsanā in the TrBh overlaps with that of bīja. Although the concept of vāsanās in the TrBh is not always equivalent to bīja, as it encompasses both active and passive meanings, both 習氣 and 熏習 in the CWSL reflect dimensions of vāsanā that align with bīja, addressing the question of how the ālayavijñāna−as a store-consciousness of bījas−can manifest dharmas or dynamically reproduce itself.
關鍵詞
- 期刊
- 臺大佛學研究
- ISSN
- 1027-1112
- 卷期
- 48期
- 出版
- 2024年12月
- 頁碼
- 113–160
- 編號
- NTUEJ00007819
同期目錄
- 關於《般若波羅蜜經》的編撰史問題 —多元中心的擴展模式宗玉媺;Yoke-meei Choong・頁 1–64
- 日本院政的佛教供養願文書寫 —從宗教與王權的交涉談起郭珮君;Pei-chun Kuo・頁 65–112
- 等流習氣與異熟習氣 —以《唯識三十頌》與《成唯識論》 為討論核心竇敏慧;Minhui Tou・頁 113–160